I really like his voice, thought it was different and interesting!

he is a semi finalist.

What are your thoughts?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eEoS3TMauGs

i think he seemed a really nice guy
but i really didnt think he was all that special, he didnt have an awful voice or anything but i didnt think he was that good
maybe that's just personal preference about voice types though

I loved him. Good voice - he reminded me a bit of David Gray.

And I thought he was gorgeous. He had lovely eyes, and a really nice smile. I really, really liked him.

But yes, good voice.

My first thought was that it is spelt 'plumber'

My first thoughts were oh gawd! do we really need another Paulo Nutini? he was just a karaoke version of him, he's even Scottish like him as well.

I thought he was really good, although he needs a bit of work though. I think Simon might realise this though. I wasn't expecting him to be as good as he was though, with him being a plumber and all. I was just expecting him to have the usual plumber type singing voice, good, but nothing to sit up and take notice of though.

I rather liked him, very engaging personality and his voice wasn't bad, but did stray into Paulo Nuttini terratory quite a lot. Rather sweet and could get through to the finals on the likability factor.

Oh yeah right, cant change it now

Was it a paulo nutini song?

He wasn't bad. But he'd make for a very anti-climactic winner.

Seen hundreds of his types on X-Factor, Pop Idol, Fame Academy and the like.

Rewind

I thought he was really good, i'd just prefer a non-singer to win this year.

I didn't think his voice was special at all and the sob story is so tiresome now.

David Gray impersonator