I'm confused that everyone loves him so much, his voice grates on me a bit and though he can hold a tune he's nothing special. I think if he'd appeared on any of the other semi-finals he would've had a much harder time getting through.
Andrew Muir - nothing special...
1 of 3
Completely agree, he just sounds like a Paolo Nutini impersonater to me, and not a great one at that. I don't get it!
I know what you mean. His voice is just like an annoying buzz that just doesn't go away. Seriously overrated.
Originally Posted by Ansildrall:
“I know what you mean. His voice is just like an annoying buzz that just doesn't go away. Seriously overrated.”
“I know what you mean. His voice is just like an annoying buzz that just doesn't go away. Seriously overrated.”
Lol, good way of putting it!
I completley agree and I was just about to start a thread on the very same subject! He is alright but he sounds way to much like James Morrison tribute act which would be alright if he was doing Stars in Their Eyes, but this is Britain\'s Got Talent.
I am also a bit bothered about him being in the final. He is Scottish and I am badly worried we will have a rerun of The X Factor last year which was ruined by Scots voting for Leon when Rhydian was clearly miles better.
If Andrew beats Faryl or George it would be such a travesty.
I am also a bit bothered about him being in the final. He is Scottish and I am badly worried we will have a rerun of The X Factor last year which was ruined by Scots voting for Leon when Rhydian was clearly miles better.
If Andrew beats Faryl or George it would be such a travesty.
Originally Posted by Honeyblossom:
“I completley agree and I was just about to start a thread on the very same subject! He is alright but he sounds way to much like James Morrison tribute act which would be alright if he was doing Stars in Their Eyes, but this is Britain\'s Got Talent.
I am also a bit bothered about him being in the final. He is Scottish and I am badly worried we will have a rerun of The X Factor last year which was ruined by Scots voting for Leon when Rhydian was clearly miles better.
If Andrew beats Faryl or George it would be such a travesty.”
“I completley agree and I was just about to start a thread on the very same subject! He is alright but he sounds way to much like James Morrison tribute act which would be alright if he was doing Stars in Their Eyes, but this is Britain\'s Got Talent.
I am also a bit bothered about him being in the final. He is Scottish and I am badly worried we will have a rerun of The X Factor last year which was ruined by Scots voting for Leon when Rhydian was clearly miles better.
If Andrew beats Faryl or George it would be such a travesty.”
When will you Rhydian fans accept that plenty of non Scots voted for Leon?
Rhydian is not the messiah - he's just another singer that didn't get enough votes to win
Originally Posted by TotalShopaholic:
“He's distinctively average. Simon wouldn't have raved about him if he auditioned for the X Factor.”
“He's distinctively average. Simon wouldn't have raved about him if he auditioned for the X Factor.”
Yeah I agree although someone not very different from him did somehow manage to win last year i go on about that alot lol but its true!
Originally Posted by Reality Sucks:
“When will you Rhydian fans accept that plenty of non Scots voted for Leon?Rhydian is not the messiah - he\'s just another singer that didn\'t get enough votes to win”
“When will you Rhydian fans accept that plenty of non Scots voted for Leon?
Rhydian is not the messiah - he\'s just another singer that didn\'t get enough votes to win”
Woah hold on! There is no need to be rude! I am just making a point. and I am not a fan of Rhydian either!
Funny how you don\'t hear much of Leon these days though isn\'t it?
Originally Posted by Honeyblossom:
“Woah hold on! There is no need to be rude! I am just making a point. and I am not a fan of Rhydian either!
Funny how you don\'t hear much of Leon these days though isn\'t it?”
“Woah hold on! There is no need to be rude! I am just making a point. and I am not a fan of Rhydian either!
Funny how you don\'t hear much of Leon these days though isn\'t it?
”
I'm not a Leon fan, but he's recording his album atm so time will tell if he will be successful or not.
The reason why I say this is because I am a Leona fan and it was quite annoying when people kept saying this about her last year. Obviously, it was worth the wait.
I thought he sang very well and deserves his place in the final.
He is nearly as good as Leon Jackson.
He is nearly as good as Leon Jackson.
Originally Posted by <Glen>:
“I'm not a Leon fan, but he's recording his album atm so time will tell if he will be successful or not.
The reason why I say this is because I am a Leona fan and it was quite annoying when people kept saying this about her last year. Obviously, it was worth the wait.”
“I'm not a Leon fan, but he's recording his album atm so time will tell if he will be successful or not.
The reason why I say this is because I am a Leona fan and it was quite annoying when people kept saying this about her last year. Obviously, it was worth the wait.
”
Yes but Leona was obviousley supertalented and had a sensational voice.
Originally Posted by pierre_gustave:
“I thought he sang very well and deserves his place in the final.
He is nearly as good as Leon Jackson.”
“I thought he sang very well and deserves his place in the final.
He is nearly as good as Leon Jackson.”
Just have to ask: that was irony, right?
I dont think his voice is amazing or anything, just good, however he has an interesting tone which i quite like.
hes much better than leon, his tone is more interesting.
hes much better than leon, his tone is more interesting.
Originally Posted by Honeyblossom:
“Woah hold on! There is no need to be rude! I am just making a point. and I am not a fan of Rhydian either!
Funny how you don\'t hear much of Leon these days though isn\'t it?”
“Woah hold on! There is no need to be rude! I am just making a point. and I am not a fan of Rhydian either!
Funny how you don\'t hear much of Leon these days though isn\'t it?
”
I didn't mean to be rude, just sick and tired of hearing about how Rhydian was robbed. Why can't people let it go? Not everyone likes classical music.
Originally Posted by utoia2007:
“I dont think his voice is amazing or anything, just good, however he has an interesting tone which i quite like.
hes much better than leon, his tone is more interesting.”
“I dont think his voice is amazing or anything, just good, however he has an interesting tone which i quite like.
hes much better than leon, his tone is more interesting.”
Dosen't take much really though
Yeah he's not bad although I don't think he'll win
Originally Posted by Honeyblossom:
“I completley agree and I was just about to start a thread on the very same subject! He is alright but he sounds way to much like James Morrison tribute act which would be alright if he was doing Stars in Their Eyes, but this is Britain\'s Got Talent.
I am also a bit bothered about him being in the final. He is Scottish and I am badly worried we will have a rerun of The X Factor last year which was ruined by Scots voting for Leon when Rhydian was clearly miles better.
If Andrew beats Faryl or George it would be such a travesty.”
“I completley agree and I was just about to start a thread on the very same subject! He is alright but he sounds way to much like James Morrison tribute act which would be alright if he was doing Stars in Their Eyes, but this is Britain\'s Got Talent.
I am also a bit bothered about him being in the final. He is Scottish and I am badly worried we will have a rerun of The X Factor last year which was ruined by Scots voting for Leon when Rhydian was clearly miles better.
If Andrew beats Faryl or George it would be such a travesty.”
I wondered how long it would take for someone to mention Andrew and the scottish vote
Leon won the X factor fair and square its been nearly 6 months-get over it!
Now back on topic- I think Andrew is very overrated, hes auditioned for X factor and didnt get through-thats not to say hes not able to sing but I think if he did get through he wouldnt last long whereas on BGT theres more variety and the fact hes more karaoke than anything else is a bit overlooked.
I think he can do well. He has a good voice and he has a nice look too
BUT he is not better than a lot of people talent wise and this is about talent and in this case, this singer is blown away by other singers and other talented people, even Jeremy Lynch.
I like him and he has a genre, a niche market but not that great.
BUT he is not better than a lot of people talent wise and this is about talent and in this case, this singer is blown away by other singers and other talented people, even Jeremy Lynch.
I like him and he has a genre, a niche market but not that great.
Originally Posted by Scottish_girl:
“I wondered how long it would take for someone to mention Andrew and the scottish vote
Leon won the X factor fair and square its been nearly 6 months-get over it!
Now back on topic- I think Andrew is very overrated, hes auditioned for X factor and didnt get through-thats not to say hes not able to sing but I think if he did get through he wouldnt last long whereas on BGT theres more variety and the fact hes more karaoke than anything else is a bit overlooked.”
“I wondered how long it would take for someone to mention Andrew and the scottish vote
Leon won the X factor fair and square its been nearly 6 months-get over it!
Now back on topic- I think Andrew is very overrated, hes auditioned for X factor and didnt get through-thats not to say hes not able to sing but I think if he did get through he wouldnt last long whereas on BGT theres more variety and the fact hes more karaoke than anything else is a bit overlooked.”
you should check out the here we go again thread lol
I really liked him - he's not my favourite (nobody can beat the wonderful Gin!!!!) and I don't think he'll win, but I think he deserves his place in the final
1 of 3
