He is Ronnie O'Sullivans twin brother.........but a lot less interesting. His gormless face and dreary voice sends me to sleep. Even the Scottish vote wont save him in the final.
Andrew Muir - nothing special...
3 of 3
I think he has an ok voice, but I don't think he is anything special. I've heard better singers in pubs, karaoke etc. His voice also sounded to me to be a bit forced and "put on."
I do sometimes think that average singers on this show are unduly praised, maybe because they seem better than they are as they are not surrounded by other singers. I think if he went on a show like the X Factor he would have been shown up as average by some of the other singers and wouldn't have got past the first round.
The same logic applies to Dean, the "West End" hopeful. I don't think he would have fared very well on Any Dream Will Do.
I do sometimes think that average singers on this show are unduly praised, maybe because they seem better than they are as they are not surrounded by other singers. I think if he went on a show like the X Factor he would have been shown up as average by some of the other singers and wouldn't have got past the first round.
The same logic applies to Dean, the "West End" hopeful. I don't think he would have fared very well on Any Dream Will Do.
he just sang a paulo nutini song in the exact same manner as paulo nutini.
If i want to hear paulo nutini, i'll listen to his album.
i was NOT impressed.
and the obvious playing up of the scottish link also got my goat. I would have no problem if they did it for everyone, such as if i appeared on it, and they stressed i was from newcastle. BUT it seems that they only do it with scottish acts, the only reason i can see is to increase their vote revenue.
if he wins, it would be an abomination.
If i want to hear paulo nutini, i'll listen to his album.
i was NOT impressed.
and the obvious playing up of the scottish link also got my goat. I would have no problem if they did it for everyone, such as if i appeared on it, and they stressed i was from newcastle. BUT it seems that they only do it with scottish acts, the only reason i can see is to increase their vote revenue.
if he wins, it would be an abomination.
I didn't like his voice. He was lucky Jeremy dropped the ball!
Sorry, but singers like him are ten a penny.
Sorry, but singers like him are ten a penny.
He was very, very sweet and appealing, but very very average as a singer - I'd have put the football bloke through as well, mind you I'm still sulking about the hoop act not getting through.
Originally Posted by Agent Krycek:
“He was very, very sweet and appealing, but very very average as a singer - I'd have put the football bloke through as well, mind you I'm still sulking about the hoop act not getting through.”
“He was very, very sweet and appealing, but very very average as a singer - I'd have put the football bloke through as well, mind you I'm still sulking about the hoop act not getting through.”
They were great weren't they?
I wish there was a wildcard place so they could get a chance to come back.
Originally Posted by Love Bear:
“They were great weren't they?
I wish there was a wildcard place so they could get a chance to come back.”
“They were great weren't they?
I wish there was a wildcard place so they could get a chance to come back.”
That would be good.
Originally Posted by Love Bear:
“They were great weren't they?
I wish there was a wildcard place so they could get a chance to come back.”
“They were great weren't they?
I wish there was a wildcard place so they could get a chance to come back.”
Absolutely fab, we were in complete hysterics throughout the act
Originally Posted by Ansildrall:
“I know what you mean. His voice is just like an annoying buzz that just doesn't go away. Seriously overrated.”
“I know what you mean. His voice is just like an annoying buzz that just doesn't go away. Seriously overrated.”
Totally agree. Faryl... good voice but also boring. Need something more visually exciting ... pity about James Stone.
Cheeky chappy with a good voice, visually exciting too....could pull off a good cabaret act. Great for a variety performance.
I agree, he was ok but he should have made more of an effort with the song choice, nice voice but he didn't knock me out, he should've done x factor.
Originally Posted by wotnot:
“I agree, he was ok but he should have made more of an effort with the song choice, nice voice but he didn't knock me out, he should've done x factor.”
“I agree, he was ok but he should have made more of an effort with the song choice, nice voice but he didn't knock me out, he should've done x factor.”
He probably did and never got past the producers auditions!
Originally Posted by Love Bear:
“He probably did and never got past the producers auditions!”
“He probably did and never got past the producers auditions!
”
He did audition for the X factor I read it somewhere.
Originally Posted by Scottish_girl:
“He did audition for the X factor I read it somewhere.”
“He did audition for the X factor I read it somewhere.”
Did he? Can you remember where he got to on the auditions?
Originally Posted by shaneyshaney:
“He is Ronnie O'Sullivans twin brother.........but a lot less interesting. His gormless face and dreary voice sends me to sleep. Even the Scottish vote wont save him in the final.”
“He is Ronnie O'Sullivans twin brother.........but a lot less interesting. His gormless face and dreary voice sends me to sleep. Even the Scottish vote wont save him in the final.”
He reminded me of Ronnie O'Sullivan when I first saw him and I can't get that thought out of my head.
Not impressed with the singing - sorry to any of his fans. 
Originally Posted by SILLY SUE:
“He reminded me of Ronnie O'Sullivan when I first saw him and I can't get that thought out of my head. Not impressed with the singing - sorry to any of his fans. ”
“He reminded me of Ronnie O'Sullivan when I first saw him and I can't get that thought out of my head.
Not impressed with the singing - sorry to any of his fans. ”
Don't say sorry. Your allowed an opinion.
Originally Posted by Latios:
“Don't say sorry. Your allowed an opinion.”
“Don't say sorry. Your allowed an opinion.
”
We all should be allowed an opinion, but knowing this type of forum (especially with visiting 'The X Factor' forum enough times which is a scary experience
), some people take a negative opinion too seriously. As long as there's no sh*t stirring, we should all value each other's opinions.
Last edited by SILLY SUE : 30-05-2008 at 20:40
Originally Posted by SILLY SUE:
“We all should be allowed an opinion, but knowing this type of forum (especially with visiting 'The X Factor' forum enough times which is a scary experience), some people take a negative opinion too seriously.
As long as there's no sh*t stirring, we should all value each other's opinions.”
“We all should be allowed an opinion, but knowing this type of forum (especially with visiting 'The X Factor' forum enough times which is a scary experience
), some people take a negative opinion too seriously. As long as there's no sh*t stirring, we should all value each other's opinions.
”
Well as long as it's constructive criticism, and not childish remarks (like i've seen on the X Factor forum) then I won't have to retaliate to anti-Andrew comments.
Originally Posted by Latios:
“Did he? Can you remember where he got to on the auditions?”
“Did he? Can you remember where he got to on the auditions?
”
I'm honestly not sure I certainly dont remember seeing him if he got past the producers, I think he said he auditioned for Pop idol as well. I'll try and find the link.
3 of 3
