Which would you go for?

I would have gone for Jeremy.

So would I. I think he has more star potential and he was good looking to so young girls would love him.

Jeremy definitely.

Too many singers and dancers this year, would have been nice to see something else go through.

Jeremy cos of his youtube videos!

Jeremy - something different and novel, and we know from the auditions that he can perform brilliantly.

Andrew was ok, but nothing special. More X Factor material.

Yeah I felt sorry for Jeromey you could tell he was gutted after his performance. They do like singers but I think he offers more variety and if he had done better they might have considered him more closley imo

I prefered Jeremy. But I can understand why the chose Andrew.

Jeremy.

We are saturated with singers on Reality Shows as it is.

Enough is enough.

I wanted Jeremy to go though. Andrew was nothing special IMO and while Jeremy made mistakes I still enjoyed his performance more.

Me too. Andrew is a singer and a good one but there are a lot out there. He's not exactly a great singer.

Jeremy has something unique.

Andrew was better on the night but Jeremy has tons more potential so i wanted jeremy to go through

I couldn't decide - I really liked them both...what a shame that one of them didn't make it

Jeremy because he is not a singer

Jeremy - ball dropped and all....

Jeremy has more star quality and more potential to entertain.
Andrew is bland and forgettable.

The shoes didn't help did they.

heart-attack fodder

i preferred Andrew but i probably would have picked jeremy if he hadnt made 2 mistakes.

i agree andrew should be on xfactor, he would of stood a good chance of winning, he wont win on BGT.

I think Jeremy should have gone through, the british public voted him into at least third place and that was with his act going wrong. To my mind there are too many singing and dancing acts in the final (if you count Strike as a dance act), Kate and Gin are the only act offering anything really different, but unfortunately I don't think they'll have much of a chance of winning.

Andrew, the other guy was boring.

I'd have voted for Jeremy, although he did drop the ball twice! T

There are too many singers now and I fear we may well suffer the backlash with Andrew (sob story I'm a plumber) bringing back the 'Leon Jackson' factor in the finals with all the Scotties voting for him, when he's just not good enough.

Jeremy.....didn't want another singer. This is a variety show. Andrew should've gone on X Factor....same with Madonna I think.