• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • TV Shows: Reality
  • Past Reality Shows
  • I'd Do Anything
Top performence of the series. And the worst
<<
<
1 of 3
>>
>
Flamethrower100
30-05-2008
Who does everyone think was the best performence of the series and the second best.
And who does everyone think was the worst.

Best. The man that got away. Jessie.
Second. Jodie the whitny housten song. Sorry I can't remember the name of it. I just loved it. It showed me that she had a chance of winning. It was beautiful and full of emotion.

The worst. Has got to be either Tara's suddenly I see, or Jessie's fighter. She's the best and the worst.
supergirlblibs
30-05-2008
Best - Sarah/Rachel Sing off
- Sarah - Mignight Train
- Jodie - I ave nothing

Worst - Tara - Suddenly I see-ah
Jessie - Fighter
Keisha - Get the Party Started
xxlouxx
30-05-2008
Best: hmmm Niamh's Wind Beneath My Wings was simply gorgeous. Loved Sam's Defying Gravity and Jodie's Send In The Clowns.

Worst: Fighter... that just made me laugh: "Tank you.. Ticker..."
hard_candy
30-05-2008
Best - Jodie with Send In The Clowns, Jessie with the Judy Garland number, and Sam with Defying Gravity.

Worst - Jessie with Fighter but it's a horrid song even when Christina does it. I've never seen anyone make it work.
devilmaycare
30-05-2008
Best - Sarah with Maybe This Time closely followed by Jodie singing Send in the Clowns and Jessie - The Man That Got Away.

Worst - Tara the week she went out. Forget what she sang because I was too shocked by the facial expressions lol. She seems like a nice girl though and I actually think she will be quite good as The Narrator!
eponine121
30-05-2008
Best: Rachel/caberet
Sarah - Midnight train to Georgia
Jodie - send in the clowns

Worst - Sam (take your pick!), mostly defying gravity and i love rck and roll
Tara - Suddenly I see
Ashley - Big spender
mickeymouse18
30-05-2008
best: the man that got away, one night only, what I did for love, cabaret, midnight train, maybe this time, send in the clowns

worst: suddenly I see/without you, hurt, for once in my life, time of my life/hero and fighter (although it was an impossible song, which I don't think any of them could have done better with)
Ashrell
30-05-2008
Best:
- Sarah: Maybe This Time/Midnight Train to Georgia/Together
- Jodie: Send in the Clowns/I Have Nothing
- Jessie: Killing Me Softly
- Rachel: I will always love you/Cabaret
- Rachel/Sarah singoff
- Niamh/Rachel singoff (I think I just like the song, though)

Worst:
- Sam: Somewhere/Hurt/Since U been gone
- Tara: Suddenly I see-ah
- Niamh: Valerie
Flamethrower100
30-05-2008
Originally Posted by supergirlblibs:
“Best - Sarah/Rachel Sing off
- Sarah - Mignight Train
- Jodie - I ave nothing

Worst - Tara - Suddenly I see-ah
Jessie - Fighter
Keisha - Get the Party Started”


Suddenly I see-ah classic comedy performence. I can't watch it without giggling.

Fighter. Was just too strange to laugh at. And I felt sorry for Jessie.

Don't remember get the party started at all.
Flamethrower100
30-05-2008
"That's a quality that I like to see", points at himself, "In my leading lady," raises eye brows and looks to be snearing.

Best performence of a over acter. John Borrowman!

He's actualy quite funny looking back. Maybe he's not so bad as I once thought.
KerryisElphie
30-05-2008
Best:

Jodie- I Have Nothing, Send in the Clowns
Keisha- ALAHNM
Rachel- Cabaret

Worst:

Sam- Defying Gravity, Somewhere
Jessie- Fighter
ImOnlyWee
30-05-2008
Best:
Sarah - Midnight Train To Georgia
Second Best:
Sarah - Maybe This Time

Worst:
Jessie - Fighter
Flamethrower100
30-05-2008
Originally Posted by KerryisElphie:
“Best:

Jodie- I Have Nothing, Send in the Clowns
Keisha- ALAHNM
Rachel- Cabaret

Worst:

Sam- Defying Gravity, Somewhere
Jessie- Fighter”

AWW Defying gravity wasn't that bad. Was it?
Although I didn't enjoy it. It can't have been that dire.
Flamethrower100
30-05-2008
Originally Posted by ImOnlyWee:
“Best:
Sarah - Midnight Train To Georgia
Second Best:
Sarah - Maybe This Time

Worst:
Jessie - Fighter”

Oh dam it I forgot Midnight train to georgia. I will now replace it with my second fave. It was amazing.
JessamyFire
30-05-2008
This worries me when I think about bad performances, with how many of Sam's I hated- Hurt, Somewhere, Survivor were all horrible. No-one else has done that many bad performances (and I do like Sam...this has just only really occured to me)
rubberplant
30-05-2008
Best

Sarah - Midnight Train To Georgia/Maybe This Time
Jodie - I Have Nothing/Send In The Clowns
Rachel - Evergreen

Worst

Jessie - Fighter
Rachel - For Once In My Life
Keisha - Lady Is A Tramp
ImOnlyWee
30-05-2008
Originally Posted by Flamethrower100:
“Oh dam it I forgot Midnight train to georgia. I will now replace it with my second fave. It was amazing. ”

It was! gota love a good old growl! haha.
smeagy28
30-05-2008
Best not in any particular order!
1 Rachel: Cabaret
2 Rachel/Sarah: As If We'd Never Said Goodbye
3 Jessie: Killing Me Softly
4 Rachel: The Way We Were
5 Niamh: Wind Beneath My Winds
6 Rachel: ALAHMN (and Ashley's)

Worst
1 Tara: Suddenly I see
2 Sam: Hurt
3 Jessie: Fighter
4 Niamh: Valerie
5 Sam: Survivor
6 Keisha: Get The Party Started

If I had to pick one from each, it'd be Rachel's Cabaret and Sam's Hurt.
supergirlblibs
30-05-2008
..... I quite liked Hurt!
river27
30-05-2008
Best
Jodie - Send in the Clowns

Worst
Niamh - Valerie
(by an absolute country mile, my favourite song ruined...)
BlurAlly
30-05-2008
Best

Jessie's Garland number
Jodie's I Have Nothing

Worst

The obvious choice is poor Tara. Anything she sang was painful to watch and hear.
But I actually think the worst was Sam's rendition of Hurt. It was so shouty and generally horrible. I was gobsmacked when the judges said they liked it!
Aleksis
30-05-2008
Best:
Keisha - Mad About the Boy
Keisha - The Lady is a Tramp
Sarah - Maybe This Time
Jodie - Send in the Clowns
Jessie - Killing Me Softly
Jessie - The Man That Got Away
Rachel - I Will Always Love You
Samantha - I Love Rock and Roll

Worst:
Samantha - Somewhere
Jessie - Fighter
Niamh - Valerie
Niamh - Moon River
Niamh - Don't Speak
Niamh - I've Got the Music in Me
Ashley - I Wanna Dance With Somebody
Tara - Suddenly I See
dudeuk87
30-05-2008
Best:
Jodie: Send in the Clowns
Rachel: Cabaret
Jessie: One Night Only
Rachel/Sam: Memory

Worst:
Tara: Suddenly I see
Niamh: Valerie
Samantha: Hurt
Keisha: Get the Party Started
eponine121
30-05-2008
Originally Posted by Ashrell:
“Best:
- Sarah: Maybe This Time/Midnight Train to Georgia/Together
- Jodie: Send in the Clowns/I Have Nothing
- Jessie: Killing Me Softly
- Rachel: I will always love you/Cabaret
- Rachel/Sarah singoff
- Niamh/Rachel singoff (I think I just like the song, though)

Worst:
- Sam: Somewhere/Hurt/Since U been gone
- Tara: Suddenly I see-ah
- Niamh: Valerie”

Oooh yes - i'd forgotten about that, it was bad!
eponine121
30-05-2008
[quote=BlurAlly;24103240]Best

Jessie's Garland number
Jodie's I Have Nothing

Worst

The obvious choice is poor Tara. Anything she sang was painful to watch and hear.
But I actually think the worst was Sam's rendition of Hurt. It was so shouty and generally horrible. I was gobsmacked when the judges said they liked it![/QUOTE]

yes it was extremely bad! i've tried to block it from my memory it was so painful
<<
<
1 of 3
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map