Top performence of the series. And the worst

2 of 3

Flamethrower100

30-05-2008

[quote=eponine121;24104274]

Originally Posted by BlurAlly:
“Best

Jessie's Garland number
Jodie's I Have Nothing

Worst

The obvious choice is poor Tara. Anything she sang was painful to watch and hear.
But I actually think the worst was Sam's rendition of Hurt. It was so shouty and generally horrible. I was gobsmacked when the judges said they liked it![/QUOTE]

yes it was extremely bad! i've tried to block it from my memory it was so painful”

Yeh it wasn't too good was it. Some bits were ok, but overall I was shocked!

sara27

30-05-2008

Best - anything by Fran incl sing offs and ALAHNM
All Jessie bar fighter

Worst Niamh Valarie
Sam Hurt
Ashley Big Spender
Keisha get the party started
Tara Suddenly I see

angel_cake

30-05-2008

If I had to pick just one from each I'd say

best - The Man That Got Away by Jessie

worst - Fighter by Jessie

DavetheScot

31-05-2008

Best: Jodie - Send In The Clowns
Second Best: Sarah - Midnight Train To Georgia

Worst: Samantha - Hurt (I love Sam, but that was truly horrible. I blame John Barrowman

)

Penny086

31-05-2008

Best: Moon river by Niamh. And all of Jessie's 'cept fighter

Worst: Jessie's Fighter was pretty bad but Ashley's Big spender was amazingly bad imo.

alsocool

31-05-2008

Best: Rachel & Sarah, As If We Never Said Goodbye

For me, this is where the series turned into a thrilling competition: two of the most favoured/popular girls fighting it out for survival and turning in a stunning performance.

MrsSpoon

31-05-2008

Worst moment - there have been a few but Jessie singing "Fighter" was embarrasing, poor Jessie struggled with that one.

Best moment - was Ashley when she sang "As Long As He Needs Me" after she was voted out. It took my breath away, she was by far the best departure singer.

Bob22A

31-05-2008

Best:
Rachel: Cabaret
Rachel/Sarah: As If We'd Never Said Goodbye
Sam:Sway
Rachel - I Will Always Love You
Samantha - I Love Rock and Roll

Worst:
Jessie - Fighter
Jodie: Send in the Clowns
Jessie: Killing Me Softly
Jodie's I Have Nothing
Niamh - Moon River
Jodie: Send in the Clowns
Niamh - I've Got the Music in Me
Tara: Suddenly I see

cantos

31-05-2008

Best: Defining Gravity - Sam

and Rachel's exit song.

Worse -Suddenly i see- Tara

eponine121

31-05-2008

Originally Posted by DavetheScot:
“Best: Jodie - Send In The Clowns
Second Best: Sarah - Midnight Train To Georgia

Worst: Samantha - Hurt (I love Sam, but that was truly horrible. I blame John Barrowman )”

can't blame JB for sams lack of talent - its not his fault she can't sing in tune and show emotion!

*Laura*

31-05-2008

Best
1. Cabaret - Rachel
2. Send in The Clowns - Jodie
3. As if We'd Never Say Goodbye - Rachel/Sarah

Worst
1. Valerie - Niamh
2. Suddenly I seeah! - Tara
3. Hurt - Sam

LaLaLaur

31-05-2008

jackbauer<3

31-05-2008

Best

Racel - Cabaret

Worst

Jessie - Fighter

woo1

31-05-2008

Best - Jodie - out here on my own
jessie - the man that got away
Sarah and rachel sing off

Worst Rachel - for once in my life

westlifefan123

31-05-2008

Best:-
Sarah- Midnight Train/Maybe This Time
AND sing-off with Rachel
Rachel- Cabaret/Beautiful
Jodie- I Have Nothing/Send In The Clowns/Out Here On My Own
Samantha- Defying Gravity/Hurt
Jessie- The Man That Got Away

Worst:-
Ashley- Evergreen/Big Spender
Tara- Suddenly I See
Keisha- The Lady Is A Tramp
Cleo- Feeling Good

From Hayley
Last edited by westlifefan123 : 31-05-2008 at 14:08

XxLiannexX

31-05-2008

Best

One night only - Jessie
My heart will go on - Keshia
I have nothing - Jodie
The man that got away - Jessie
ALAHNM - Keshia

Worst

Valerayyyyyyyyyyyy - Niamh
Hey big spender - Ash
Suddenly ahh see - Tara
For once in my life - Rachel
I wanna dance with somebody - Ash

Ignazio

31-05-2008

Originally Posted by sara27:
“Best - anything by Fran incl sing offs and ALAHNM
All Jessie bar fighter

Worst Niamh Valarie
Sam Hurt
Ashley Big Spender
Keisha get the party started
Tara Suddenly I see”

Bless you Sarah and Lal - I though I was searching in vain for Fran's numbers.

After Fran - it has to be Jessie for me; Killing me Softly and The man who got away, followed by Jodie's Send in the Clowns.

Golden anemone

31-05-2008

Best - Niamh and Rachel's sing off

Worst - Ashley's Hey Big Spender

peeve

31-05-2008

Restricting my choices just to the remaining contestants (I know that wasn't the brief, but still):

Best performance:

Jodie: Send in the clowns
Jessie: The man who got away
Samantha: Sway

Worst performance:

Jodie: Luck be a lady
Jessie: Fighter
Samantha: Since u been gone

SheShe

31-05-2008

Best was Killing Me Softly by Jessie

Worst was Defying Gravity by Sam (though Fighter was pretty bad too and I am a huge Jessie fan)

I liked almost everything that Sarah did too...

Babo

31-05-2008

Best moment - was Ashley when she sang "As Long As He Needs Me" after she was voted out. It took my breath away, she was by far the best departure singer.[/quote]

I agree - it was fantastic.....

Holly Oaks

31-05-2008

Best

Niamh - Wind Beneath My Wings
Samantha - Defying Gravity
Jessie - The Man That Got Away
Sarah - Ironic
Rachel - Caberet
Olivers - Give A Little Love

Worst

Jessie - Fighter
Ashley - Big Spender
Tara - Suddenly I See

liv_x

31-05-2008

Best
Rachel- cabaret
Rachel - the way we were
Anything my rachel really

Worst
Jessie - fighter
Sam - hurt
Tara - ALAHNM (so painful on the ears)

Pinksheep87

31-05-2008

Best:- (in no particular order)

Rachel - I Will Always Love You/Cabaret (and ironically, all of the songs she sang in the sing-off's!!)
Sarah - Get Here/Ironic
Jodie - Send In The Clowns/Chasing Pavements
Niamh - Wind Beneath My Wings
Jessie - River Deep, Mountain High
Ashley - As Long As He Needs Me (along with Rachel's - both had so much emotion and passion.)

Worst:-

Tara - you guessed it!! Suddenly I See
Amy - R.E.S.P.E.C.T
Sam - Defying Gravity (because it was clearly edited so she wouldn't flop on the higher notes, which ruined the song)

supergirlblibs

31-05-2008

I want to add Keishas ALAHNM to my worst list!

2 of 3