I felt sorry for Andrew Muir tonight. His voice isnt horrific, I think people are too precious with that song. Saying that, it was the wrong song choice for him (whoevers decision it was) and if he would have sung a james morrison song he may have fared better with the judges.
Mind u, i think the GP really didnt want a singer to win this series. and he was the only person in the final who was a standard singer, so i think that went against him.
He has a good voice and seems like an amiable guy, and so when the judges were overly harsh, u could see how much it affected his confidence - to the point that when he was asked if he thought he would win, he said definitley not and he just looked dejected throughout after that. I didnt think he deserved it
Mind u, i think the GP really didnt want a singer to win this series. and he was the only person in the final who was a standard singer, so i think that went against him.
He has a good voice and seems like an amiable guy, and so when the judges were overly harsh, u could see how much it affected his confidence - to the point that when he was asked if he thought he would win, he said definitley not and he just looked dejected throughout after that. I didnt think he deserved it



