Jessie could not act!!!

4 of 11

hippo3

01-06-2008

Originally Posted by dave782:
“Hi islastar...Thats the truth of it. Hippo3 is a troll looking to inflame reaction. Sam Jessie and Jodie provided a great Show tonight. Hippo 3 probably cant even tie their own Shoelaces. ”

how little you know about me!

islastar

01-06-2008

Originally Posted by hippo3:
“thats why she won”

I'm not saying people wanted her for the part, she's very young. Most people however are not refusing to accept the fact the Jessie had talent.

geogchick

01-06-2008

Originally Posted by hippo3:
“thats why she won”

yes most people - she came second

You still haven't said who you were supporting or what the point of this thread is?

hardylane

01-06-2008

She can sing ... no doubt... but she's just no West End. She can't act... it's really that simple.... Oliver the Musical has a lot of TALKING...

hippo3

01-06-2008

Originally Posted by islastar:
“I'm not saying people wanted her for the part, she's very young. Most people however are not refusing to accept the fact the Jessie had talent.”

but she didn't. my opinion!!

islastar

01-06-2008

Originally Posted by hippo3:
“but she didn't. my opinion!!”

What I'm saying is that most people disagree with your opinion.

DavidA_UK

01-06-2008

Hippo3 are you really eponine 000?

geogchick

01-06-2008

Hippo, she didn't win. - so what is your problem?

Why do you feel the need to attack her ability/inability?

hippo3

01-06-2008

Originally Posted by geogchick:
“yes most people - she came second

You still haven't said who you were supporting or what the point of this thread is?”

duh....not most people

who i supported has no relation to this thread! i discussing Jessie and her lac of talent!

i am expressing my opinion! thats the threads purpose

islastar

01-06-2008

Originally Posted by hippo3:
“duh....not most people

who i supported has no relation to this thread! i discussing Jessie and her lac of talent!

i am expressing my opinion! thats the threads purpose”

To have an unnecessary dig at the runner up?

hippo3

01-06-2008

Originally Posted by islastar:
“To have an unnecessary dig at the runner up?”

no..............well yes

dave782

01-06-2008

Originally Posted by hippo3:
“how little you know about me!”

It's more than enough to be honest.

It was a great Final.

islastar

01-06-2008

Originally Posted by hippo3:
“no..............well yes ”

Charming. Well I think you've achieved that now. I hope you're happy

geogchick

01-06-2008

Doh! The question was whether she was talented? My favourite was Jessie but I thought Jodie was talented. I assume it worked the other way round too. Therefore the majority of people thought she was talented.

Flamethrower100

01-06-2008

He/she has nothing better to do with it's life unfortunatly.
Probaly think's it's funny. I think it talks bull.
Either it's a very nasty person or it's brain dead. That's all I've got to say. I thought Jessie was brilliant. So do a lot of people apparently.
If I was voting because of sympathy I wouldn't have chosen Jessie.
Jodie had more of a sob story.

hippo3

01-06-2008

Originally Posted by geogchick:
“Doh! The question was whether she was talented? My favourite was Jessie but I thought Jodie was talented. I assume it worked the other way round too. Therefore the majority of people thought she was talented.”

no fact! and i have seen evidence to suggest otherwise plus just a little thing SHE DID NOT WIN!

Flamethrower100

01-06-2008

It's I am discussing. Not I discussing. Duh.

soapaddictDS

01-06-2008

Originally Posted by eponine121:
“No - she can't really act, and her accent is oo strong, her diction is also terrible. But she can show emotion really well when she performs singing wise, and i think with a few years training the accent can be calmed, diction improved, acting improved and she'd be a stronger performer then who could consistantly do well in a lead role.”

i agree!

hippo3

01-06-2008

Originally Posted by Flamethrower100:
“He/she has nothing better to do with it's life unfortunatly.
Probaly think's it's funny. I think it talks bull.
Either it's a very nasty person or it's brain dead. That's all I've got to say. I thought Jessie was brilliant. So do a lot of people apparently.
If I was voting because of sympathy I wouldn't have chosen Jessie.
Jodie had more of a sob story.”

dont make this personal or insult me! i suggest you read the forum rules again!

Flamethrower100

01-06-2008

Originally Posted by hippo3:
“no fact! and i have seen evidence to suggest otherwise plus just a little thing SHE DID NOT WIN!”

Second is pretty big though.

geogchick

01-06-2008

I'm sorry you are clearly missing he point.

It is undisputed whether the majority of people saw her as Nancy. They didn't.

You have no proof whether the majority ot people thought she was talented. My guess is, considering, she came 2nd out of 10000 the majority of people did see her as talented

hippo3

01-06-2008

Originally Posted by Flamethrower100:
“Second is pretty big though.”

but not the most!

Flamethrower100

01-06-2008

Originally Posted by hippo3:
“dont make this personal or insult me! i suggest you read the forum rules again!”

I didn't say you I said It.

islastar

01-06-2008

Originally Posted by hippo3:
“no fact! and i have seen evidence to suggest otherwise plus just a little thing SHE DID NOT WIN!”

Yes but she came very close. Anyhoo the person who comes first isn't always the most successful.

soapaddictDS

01-06-2008

Originally Posted by mickeymouse18:
“she can definitetly act and I think her ALAHNM proved it, head and shoulders above the rest, the emotion in it was incredible, completely believable, and not a hint of an accent”

what does ALAHNM mean?

4 of 11