ooh, good game! didn't have time to rewatch them all, so just chose the ones i was most interested in...
“Cabaret”
i never really like helena but looking back that was a really great performance,and with some amazing dancing, but rachel's was just astonishing, and FAR superior vocally, so i would definitely pick rachel.
“Anyone Who Had A Heart”
didnt rate sam on this much at the time but looking back was pretty damn good vocally, but i cant get past the fact that she has NO emotions or acting ability at all, so overall would pick siobhan, although her vocal was much weaker...a combination would be amazing.
“Big Spender”
Again, did think much of ash's at the time, but now i see she actually did some really nice things with it, but still, abi was just awesome in this so the hands down winner for me!
“Maybe This Time”
didnt like the trio really at all, but out of them i'd say jodie best, then jessie, sam was just lame.
of the solos, this is a tough one as abi and sarah were both my absolute faves. just watched them both next to each other, they're played very differently, sarah's is very emotional which is probably more appropriate for the song, and i always love her voice. abi's was kind of sexier, and more fun, and i think her i prefer her vocal to sarah's in this, (despite the little crack!) so overall i'd say abi, but both were really amazing.
“As Long As He Needs Me”
Didn't really like connie's at all.
of the nancy's i'm gonna separate jodie and jessie from the others because it was such a different context i dont think its fair to compare.
so, out of those two definitely jessie.
out of the others, i'd rank them in this order: ashley, sarah, fran, keisha, amy, then after that i don't really care!
