Originally Posted by Golden anemone:
“I hadn't remembered until I watched this and the original that the arrangement for Jessie and Gwion was different. In Siobhan's and the film version the childern sing the first half of the song to Truly and she replies before they sing together whereas Jessie and Gwion sing alternate lines from the beginning. It meant there was no need for Jessie to do lots of "acting without singing" while Gwion was singing to her. I wonder whether that's why they changed it?
”
“I hadn't remembered until I watched this and the original that the arrangement for Jessie and Gwion was different. In Siobhan's and the film version the childern sing the first half of the song to Truly and she replies before they sing together whereas Jessie and Gwion sing alternate lines from the beginning. It meant there was no need for Jessie to do lots of "acting without singing" while Gwion was singing to her. I wonder whether that's why they changed it?
”
Well I don't think so. It was a duet like the other Nancys and olivers did, and they were dancing. The film version was a lot longer I think, and they had the beach and everything and the bay. I think Siobhan was supposed to try and act it, to prove herself as an actress. I thought she did quite well, but the version of the song was slow and annoying, for me anyway.



