• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • TV Shows: Reality
  • Past Reality Shows
  • I'd Do Anything
**OFFICIAL HDYSAPLM Canada** (first maria school vid here as well)
<<
<
11 of 18
>>
>
LaLaLaur
03-07-2008
Okay I couldn't not look at the results- WTF!?
BuddyBontheNet
03-07-2008
I was thinking about the result this week (I had lie down afterwards ) and it occurred to me that there is such a high standard of singing talent in this group, that maybe when it comes to the sing off Simon might choose on the basis of "Does her face fit?".

Out of the two in the sing off this week, the one that stayed looks more like my idea of Maria than the one who left (even though the one that stayed is my least favourite by miles).

When does everyone think we can use names?
CaroUK
03-07-2008
I think the one who left should have stayed - the one who stayed I just don't get at all - she is the weakest one in there (the Tara of this show?)

I would think we can use names now - we're nearly at the next show

Anyone else think they had weird songs this week?
BuddyBontheNet
03-07-2008
Originally Posted by CaroUK:
“I think the one who left should have stayed - the one who stayed I just don't get at all - she is the weakest one in there (the Tara of this show?)

I would think we can use names now - we're nearly at the next show

Anyone else think they had weird songs this week?”

So my download instructions worked then Carol LOL!?

How many G&Ts did it take?

I think Jayme is by far the weakest in this group and two better Marias have now gone home. She didn't like her comments either which won't go down well.
LaLaLaur
03-07-2008
I'd say just use names... I don't mind! Does anyone else? Lol!

Download is taking foreeevveerrr!
CaroUK
03-07-2008
Yes thanks Buddy - and I'll just say that more than 1 was required :lol:
LaLaLaur
03-07-2008
Watching show 1, still don't like the set very much
BuddyBontheNet
03-07-2008
Originally Posted by LaLaLaur:
“Watching show 1, still don't like the set very much ”

Show 1??? Hurry and catch up so we can chat LOL!
Shaunie93
03-07-2008
Does any1 have a favourite yet!????
LaLaLaur
03-07-2008
Not show 1! Show... 5! I meant show 1 of this weeks shows! Lol! I just have show 6 to watch, but I know the result! I'm still loving Donna, but I'm still questioning her suitability to Maria (I almost wrote Nancy there, but I didn't!) Katie was much better this week, as was Janna!
LaLaLaur
03-07-2008
And also, John Barrowman's gone a little overboard with the eye makeup. Haha! And Marisa was FAB. Much of an improvement from last week! Still not 100% convinced on the vocal though... but she has stunning eyes... lol!
BuddyBontheNet
04-07-2008
My favourites are Donna, Janna & Marissa - with Donna & Janna ahead of Marissa.

I can't see them willingly choosing Donna because again like Jodie, her build won't suit them.

I think Janna will win as she ticks all the boxes.
CaroUK
04-07-2008
Early faves are Elicia, Marisa and Donna

Don't know why Jayme was saved over Allie and Tamara is another concert singer
LaLaLaur
04-07-2008
I think Elicia will win...
BuddyBontheNet
04-07-2008
Originally Posted by CaroUK:
“Early faves are Elicia, Marisa and Donna

Don't know why Jayme was saved over Allie and Tamara is another concert singer”

I'm not keen on Tamara's voice at all.

Originally Posted by LaLaLaur:
“I think Elicia will win...”

She's definitely a favourite with the judges I think.
SnoopMK
04-07-2008
Janna is my favorite, but I also like Elicia and Donna, even though Donna's voice has not struck me as ideal for Maria, wonderful as it may be. Oddly enough, Marisa is leading in the poll on the official website, even though she was in the bottom 2 the first week. I think she was much better the second week, but I'm still not sure about her as Maria.
LaLaLaur
04-07-2008
I think they said we'd be hearing Donna's "head voice" next week, so that should be interesting! I really like her as a performer too, she's captivating!
BuddyBontheNet
04-07-2008
Originally Posted by SnoopMK:
“Janna is my favorite, but I also like Elicia and Donna, even though Donna's voice has not struck me as ideal for Maria, wonderful as it may be. Oddly enough, Marisa is leading in the poll on the official website, even though she was in the bottom 2 the first week. I think she was much better the second week, but I'm still not sure about her as Maria.”

Could you post a link to the poll?
Shaunie93
04-07-2008
From what I've seen soo far Elicia and Donna really stand out for me!
eandh99
04-07-2008
This is the homepage for the show itself, and the link to the poll is right there in the middle of the page.
BuddyBontheNet
04-07-2008
Originally Posted by eandh99:
“This is the homepage for the show itself, and the link to the poll is right there in the middle of the page.”

Thanks! I have been on the site so many times and never noticed that before LOL!
PenguinBear
05-07-2008
I can't help but compare this to the BBC show and this seems like a cheap imitation. Maybe it would have been better if they had done a different show.

BBC Set > CBC Set
BBC clothes > CBC Clothes
Graham Norton > Canadian gay guy playing the Graham Norton role
ALW > Simon, the guy playing the ALW role.

And I dunno, I just really can't stand that woman judge. She annoys me. Barrowman seems annoyed by her too. (he was making funny faces and jestures while she was talking)

On a positive note the guy who is playing the John Barrowman Role is doing a pretty good job.
piper333
05-07-2008
I don't understand how you guys like the sterile bbc set better than the warm spiral stair case and larger space of the cbc set

and as for the clothes... Penguin Bear! come on!!!

the rest i agree with.
Shaunie93
05-07-2008
Thanks for the link eandh99!
BuddyBontheNet
05-07-2008
The clothes in this show are much better than in the UK show LOL!

Piper sorry, but as I said the Canadian set is naff - really 80's LOL!

The singing standard is better though IMHO.
<<
<
11 of 18
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map