I thought that Rachel and Sam's was the best. In I'd do anything.
Aiofe and Abi's in HDYSAPLM.
I'm really not sure about ADWD.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KhvwfsXKVXs

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AjLBCbBN99o

Sarah and Rachel's was the best in I'd Do Anything by a country mile!

Sarah and Rachel's deffo! It gives me shivers and makes me cry eek!

there are two threads on this that could be bumped

- rib rib rib

i have to go back now and think on an answer.

Sarah's and Rachel's most definitely. The best out of all three series.

Undoubtedly Sarah and Rachel's. I've listened to it loads of time and it still gives me shivers!

To go with the trend, Sarah and Rachel's sing off was the best one in the competition - one of the highlights of the series. I also enjoyed Rachel and Niamh's singoff, for some reason, but maybe it's just because I love the song.

Sarah and Rachel gave me goosebumps! I also like Fran and Amys!!

Sarah and Rachel by a looooooong shot. It's AMAZING. Best of all 3 series I'd say. Sends shivers down my spine!! And it makes me a little teary...

I also really liked Fran and Amy's

Rachel/Niamh
Rachel/Sam
Rachel/Sarah

for me

I didn't even really like Rachel that much but always did in the sing-off

I also liked Tara/Keisha but only cos I loved that song and felt Tara actually shone in it, where as I didn't like any of her other performances

Rachel and Sarah's hands down. It had me in tears and sent shivers down my spine. Absolutely amazing.

Loved Rachel/Sams as well.

Rachel and Sarahs was amazing, sarah was the only one out of the three sing offs rachel was in to match her. Rachel comes alive when she is singing musical theatre songs, i didnt like her till her first sing off!

Have to admit wasn't a huge Rachel Fan - Not for any reason in particular just people I liked more but loved all her singoff performances and also Frans sections in both of her singoffs were really good

ADWD.........oh it was Daniel..........

I like Amy/ Fran and Ashley/Fran too.

I think those three were given a raw deal by IDA.

Yeah but that sing off lose points for having Lewis in it.

Just watched Abi/Aoife sing off - that was lovely.

Aoife seemed really gutted Abi was going.

Were they not best friends at drama school or something? Aww, I love Abi

I never watched HDYSAPLM, I'm just watching it now via you tube. So far Abi/Aoife are my faves. It must've been difficult to be up against each other.

Have to say I agree with the Sarah/Rachel group. It helped that they had a brilliant song to sing but they were both on top form and it showed as ALW couldn't think of a real reason to get rid of Sarah.

Yeh they were best friends, and they auditioned at the same time. And both got through.
They were my favourites too.

Gotta be Fran/Ashley - nothing against Ashley but how the hell did she survive? - loved Abi in HDYSAPLM - too.

Because the panel liked her

Or they felt sorry for her - thus swinging ALW's opinion.

Don't misunderstand me - Ashley suffered some unnecessarily harsh judgement - but to save her over Fran beggared belief.

Not really if you consider ALW's track record. It was someone with MT experience over someone who hadn't worked since graduating. In those cases ALW almost always keeps the less experienced person.