• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • TV Shows: Reality
  • The Apprentice
The Apprentice Awards 2008:Shortlist
<<
<
2 of 3
>>
>
Cadence
22-06-2008
Originally Posted by Vivadiva:
“Yes, I made up a shortlist based on the number of votes received and drew up a list of the top 4 (or roundabouts) for each.

This may not be a reflection of your opinions but is of the forum as a whole...”

Well not really because if a forum member doesn't have a choice amongst those now available in the categories they either have to choose another candidate who doesn't reflect their feelings or abstain from voting. Fair enough for an 'awards' ceremony, but you can't claim it reflects the opinions of the forum as a whole.
zaidah
22-06-2008
Favourite Candidate: Lee, Lucinda, Raef, Sara
Least Favourite Candidate: Alex, Helene, Jenny C, Michael
Favourite Task: Cars, Laundry, Morocco, Wedding
Most Suited Candidate: Claire, Lee, Raef, Simon
Favourite Aide to Sir Alan: Margaret, Nick
Best Candidate Personality: Lee, Lucinda, Raef, Simon
Worst Candidate Personality: Alex, Helene, Jenny C, Michael
Most Over-Rated Candidate: Alex, Helene, Lucinda, Michael
Most Under-Rated Candidate: Jenny M, Raef, Sara, Simon
Most Shocking Decision: The Final 4, Raef's firing over Michael, Shazia's firing over Jenny C, Simon's firing over Claire
Best 'You're Fired' Moment: Adrian's frank opinion of Michael, The Badger, Helene vs Lucinda, Michael McIntyre, Raef's appearance, Support for Shazia, Victoria Wood, Vanessa vs Jenny C
Muttley76
22-06-2008
Originally Posted by Cadence:
“Well not really because if a forum member doesn't have a choice amongst those now available in the categories they either have to choose another candidate who doesn't reflect their feelings or abstain from voting. Fair enough for an 'awards' ceremony, but you can't claim it reflects the opinions of the forum as a whole. ”

The rules were very clear right from the word go, if you don't like it no one is forcing you to vote. I think your being quite rude actually. If you had a better idea why didn't you do it yourself?
Cadence
22-06-2008
Originally Posted by Muttley76:
“The rules were very clear right from the word go, if you don't like it no one is forcing you to vote. I think your being quite rude actually. If you had a better idea why didn't you do it yourself?”

I was answering a point on a claim for the representative nature of it, not triying to be antagonistic.
Muttley76
22-06-2008
Originally Posted by Cadence:
“I was answering a point on a claim for the representative nature of it, not triying to be antagonistic.”

with all due respect this isn't a thread for debate is it? Show some respect to the OP, who has gone out of her way to put this together. To answer your question though, most of us nominated at least one person who hasn't made the short list I would think, however rather than making a fuss about it we have switched to the nominee that most reflects our views. If your unable to do the same, then don't vote, but please stop disrupting the thread and either vote or leave it be.....
ForeverBeret
22-06-2008
Favourite Candidate: Lucinda
Least Favourite Candidate: Alex
Favourite Task: Morocco
Most Suited Candidate: Claire
Favourite Aide to Sir Alan: Margaret
Best Candidate Personality: Lucinda
Worst Candidate Personality: Jenny C
Most Over-Rated Candidate: Alex
Most Under-Rated Candidate: Simon
Most Shocking Decision: The Final 4
Best 'You're Fired' Moment: The Badger
Donna16
22-06-2008
Favourite Candidate: Lucinda

Least Favourite Candidate: Jenny C

Favourite Task: Wedding

Most Suited Candidate: Claire

Favourite Aide to Sir Alan: Margaret

Best Candidate Personality: Lucinda

Worst Candidate Personality: Jenny C

Most Over-Rated Candidate: Helene

Most Under-Rated Candidate: Simon

Most Shocking Decision: Raef's firing over Michael

Best 'You're Fired' Moment: Helene vs Lucinda,
Hera
22-06-2008
Favourite Candidate: Raef
Least Favourite Candidate: Jenny C
Favourite Task: Morocco
Most Suited Candidate: Claire
Favourite Aide to Sir Alan: Margaret
Best Candidate Personality:Raef
Worst Candidate Personality: Jenny C
Most Over-Rated Candidate: Lucinda
Most Under-Rated Candidate: Simon
Most Shocking Decision: Raef's firing over Michael
Best 'You're Fired' Moment: Adrian's frank opinion of Michael
tally
22-06-2008
Originally Posted by Vivadiva:
“After a good few votes, a shortlist has been drawn up for FM to vote before next Sunday's Awards Ceremony. Please vote by posting your chosen recipients on here or through PM.

You have a week to vote- good luck! ”

Right. ici les votes de la Cornish ( well one Cornish maid anyway )

Favourite Candidate: Raef
Least Favourite Candidate: Michael
Favourite Task: Morocco
Most Suited Candidate: Claire
Favourite Aide to Sir Alan: Margaret,
Best Candidate Personality: Raef
Worst Candidate Personality: Jenny C
Most Over-Rated Candidate: [/b]Alex[/b]
Most Under-Rated Candidate: Simon
Most Shocking Decision: Shazia's firing over Jenny C
Best 'You're Fired' Moment: Vanessa vs Jenny C
sveknu
22-06-2008
After a good few votes, a shortlist has been drawn up for FM to vote before next Sunday's Awards Ceremony. Please vote by posting your chosen recipients on here or through PM.

Favourite Candidate: Sara
Least Favourite Candidate: Michael
Favourite Task: Morocco
Most Suited Candidate: Lee
Favourite Aide to Sir Alan: Margaret
Best Candidate Personality: Lee
Worst Candidate Personality: Jenny C
Most Over-Rated Candidate: Lucinda
Most Under-Rated Candidate: Sara
Most Shocking Decision: Raef's firing over Michael
Best 'You're Fired' Moment: Adrian's frank opinion of Michael
DavetheScot
22-06-2008
Favourite Candidate: Sara
Least Favourite Candidate: Jenny C
Favourite Task: Morocco
Most Suited Candidate: Raef
Favourite Aide to Sir Alan: Margaret
Best Candidate Personality: Simon
Worst Candidate Personality: Jenny C
Most Over-Rated Candidate: Michael
Most Under-Rated Candidate: Sara
Most Shocking Decision: Shazia's firing over Jenny C
Best 'You're Fired' Moment: Support for Shazia

All my choices made the shortlist!
ThaGazBoi
23-06-2008
Favourite Candidate: Sara
Least Favourite Candidate: Jenny C
Favourite TasK; Morocco
Most Suited Candidate: Claire
Favourite Aide to Nick: Margaret
Best Candidate Personalitly: Lee
Worst Candidate Personalitly: Jenny C
Most Over-Rated Candidate: Alex
Least Under-Rated Candidate: Sara
Most Shocking Decision: Shazia's firing over Jenny C
Best 'You're Fired' Moment: The Badger
The Body
23-06-2008
Favourite Candidate: Lucinda
Least Favourite Candidate: Jenny C
Favourite Task: Laundry
Most Suited Candidate: Simon
Favourite Aide to Sir Alan: Margaret
Best Candidate Personality: Lucinda
Worst Candidate Personality: Jenny C
Most Over-Rated Candidate: Michael
Most Under-Rated Candidate: Sara
Most Shocking Decision: Shazia's firing over Jenny C
Best 'You're Fired' Moment: Helene vs Lucinda
cole09mcfc
23-06-2008
Favourite Candidate: Raef
Least Favourite Candidate: Jenny C
Favourite Task: Laundry
Most Suited Candidate: Raef
Favourite Aide to Sir Alan: Margaret
Best Candidate Personality: Simon
Worst Candidate Personality: Jenny C
Most Over-Rated Candidate: Alex
Most Under-Rated Candidate: Raef
Most Shocking Decision: Raef's firing over Michael
Best 'You're Fired' Moment: Michael McIntyre
artgirl73
23-06-2008
Favourite Candidate: Raef,
Least Favourite Candidate: Alex
Favourite Task: Morocco
Most Suited Candidate: Lee
Favourite Aide to Sir Alan: Margaret
Best Candidate Personality: Raef
Worst Candidate Personality: Jenny C
Most Over-Rated Candidate: Helene
Most Under-Rated Candidate: Simon
Most Shocking Decision: Raef's firing over Michael
Best 'You're Fired' Moment: Vanessa vs Jenny C
Drood
23-06-2008
Favourite Candidate: Raef
Least Favourite Candidate: Michael
Favourite Task: Wedding
Most Suited Candidate: Lee
Favourite Aide to Sir Alan: Margaret
Best Candidate Personality: Raef
Worst Candidate Personality: Michael
Most Over-Rated Candidate: Helene
Most Under-Rated Candidate: Raef
Most Shocking Decision: Shazia's firing over Jenny C
Best 'You're Fired' Moment: Michael McIntyre
kyle_y1992
23-06-2008
Favourite Candidate: Raef
Least Favourite Candidate: Michael
Favourite Task: Laundry
Most Suited Candidate: Claire
Favourite Aide to Sir Alan: Margaret
Best Candidate Personality: Raef
Worst Candidate Personality: Michael
Most Over-Rated Candidate: Alex/Michael
Most Under-Rated Candidate: Raef
Most Shocking Decision: Raef's firing over Michael
Best 'You're Fired' Moment: Victoria Wood
Scissor*Sister
23-06-2008
Favourite Candidate:Lucinda
Least Favourite Candidate: Alex
Favourite Task: Morocco
Most Suited Candidate: Claire
Favourite Aide to Sir Alan: Margaret
Best Candidate Personality:Raef
Worst Candidate Personality: Alex
Most Over-Rated Candidate: Helene
Most Under-Rated Candidate: Simon
Most Shocking Decision: Raef's firing over Michael
Best 'You're Fired' Moment: Adrian's frank opinion of Michael
Jacob_bb
23-06-2008
Favourite Candidate: Lucinda
Least Favourite Candidate: Jenny C
Favourite Task: Morocco
Most Suited Candidate: Claire
Favourite Aide to Sir Alan: Margaret
Best Candidate Personality: Lucinda
Worst Candidate Personality: Jenny C
Most Over-Rated Candidate: Alex
Most Under-Rated Candidate: Sara
Most Shocking Decision: Shazia's firing over Jenny C
Best 'You're Fired' Moment: Michael McIntyre
2LO
23-06-2008
Favourite Candidate:Lucinda
Least Favourite Candidate: Alex
Favourite Task: Morocco
Most Suited Candidate: Claire
Favourite Aide to Sir Alan: Margaret
Best Candidate Personality: Lucinda
Worst Candidate Personality: Alex
Most Over-Rated Candidate: Raef
Most Under-Rated Candidate: Shazia
Most Shocking Decision: Shazia's firing
Best 'You're Fired' Moment: Adrian's frank opinion of Michael
Muttley76
23-06-2008
Originally Posted by 2LO:
“Favourite Candidate:Lucinda
Least Favourite Candidate: Alex
Favourite Task: Morocco
Most Suited Candidate: Claire
Favourite Aide to Sir Alan: Margaret
Best Candidate Personality: Lucinda
Worst Candidate Personality: Alex
Most Over-Rated Candidate: Raef
Most Under-Rated Candidate: Shazia
Most Shocking Decision: Shazia's firing
Best 'You're Fired' Moment: Adrian's frank opinion of Michael”

You can't vote for Raef he isn't on the shortlist...

eta: you can't vote for Shazia either!
yakutz
23-06-2008
Favourite Candidate: Raef
Least Favourite Candidate: Jenny C
Favourite Task: Morocco
Most Suited Candidate: Lee
Favourite Aide to Sir Alan: Margaret
Best Candidate Personality: Raef
Worst Candidate Personality: Michael
Most Over-Rated Candidate: Lucinda
Most Under-Rated Candidate: Jenny M
Most Shocking Decision: Shazia's firing over Jenny C
Best 'You're Fired' Moment: Michael McIntyre
2LO
23-06-2008
Originally Posted by Muttley76:
“You can't vote for Raef he isn't on the shortlist...

eta: you can't vote for Shazia either!”

Better just discount my entry then.
Mazzarin
23-06-2008
All of it or just the invalid answers?
InigoMontoya
23-06-2008
Originally Posted by Muttley76:
“For goodness sake peeps...you had a chance to nominate people in the other thread. She clearly didn't get enough votes to make the short list...there is nothing unfair or under hand about it at all.

eta: and wouldn't you know it, it appears that neither of the people complaining here bothered to vote in the nominations round, therefore it's your own fault...”

I didn't see the earlier thread. I wouldn't have expected the need for shortening a list when there's only 16 people, I must admit, but I certainly intended no disrespect to the OP. My question was genuine and not a complaint. Now that you've made me aware of this, I will, of course, bow out as I'm not now able to register my own opinion.
<<
<
2 of 3
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map