• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • The X Factor
The HANNAH Appreciating Place
<<
<
4 of 5
>>
>
Beer
05-10-2008
Originally Posted by The Body:
“Well she's done Mercy twice, so I'll go with Warwick Avenue. ”

I am sure she'd do well in that but it's UK and US number ones. Would be interesting to see what she does.
Off_the_hook13
05-10-2008
I'm gutted with the result, especially considering Cheryl was telling Hannah she is one of the best in the competition vocally then tells her she's not through.
She seemed too upset to even hug Dermot.

IMO Hannah really deserved to be in the final 12 and should have been picked over Alex, it would have been the perfect final three for me if she had been.

I know there have been rumours of a wildcard happening during the live shows, not sure if it will happen but if it does I really hope Hannah is given a second chance.

Deja Vu_
05-10-2008
Hannah should have gone through to the final. I hope they give her a second chance as well. Alex and Laura deserved to go through but so did Hannah. I don't care much for Diana.
Beer
05-10-2008
Originally Posted by Off_the_hook13:
“I'm gutted with the result, especially considering Cheryl was telling Hannah she is one of the best in the competition vocally then tells her she's not through.
She seemed too upset to even hug Dermot.

IMO Hannah really deserved to be in the final 12 and should have been picked over Alex, it would have been the perfect final three for me if she had been.

I know there have been rumours of a wildcard happening during the live shows, not sure if it will happen but if it does I really hope Hannah is given a second chance.

”

I don't know what the big deal with Alex is because there are a thousand alex's in the history of the charts who just shout in songs but like I say, they need a fall guy and I feel Alex will be that fall guy.

Hannah wasn't picked because she was a threat and she wouldn't have been an easy fall guy on the live shows..
yorkshirebread
05-10-2008
So I assume this wildcard thing will come to nothing then??
Beer
05-10-2008
Originally Posted by yorkshirebread:
“So I assume this wildcard thing will come to nothing then?? ”

We know nothing yet.

Not so long ago she was asked to remove herself from a Facebook appreciation page and she also closed down her Facebook page too...
Off_the_hook13
05-10-2008
Originally Posted by Beer:
“I don't know what the big deal with Alex is because there are a thousand alex's in the history of the charts who just shout in songs but like I say, they need a fall guy and I feel Alex will be that fall guy.

Hannah wasn't picked because she was a threat and she wouldn't have been an easy fall guy on the live shows..”

I agree 100%. Ok Alex is good but she isn't outstanding, Hannah was amazing and she isn't exactly your everyday X Factor contestant. You see thousands of the same sort of people with the same voices at the audtions but Hannah was different to a lot of what we've seen before.
Tbh I don't think Cheryl could handle telling Alex she didn't make it for the 2nd time which would have helped influence her decision.

I don't think Simon would have been very pleased when he found out Hannah was turned down, he seemed to really like her and its not often he says someone is "incredible" and "one to watch." I wish Simon had got the girls now cause Hannah would have definately got through.

She would have been a serious contender if she'd got through, even the bookies had her as the favourite at one point and quite a lot of people seem gutted that she didn't get through. Big mistake imo.
Bob22A
05-10-2008
Originally Posted by Deja Vu_:
“Hannah should have gone through to the final. I hope they give her a second chance as well. Alex and Laura deserved to go through but so did Hannah. I don't care much for Diana.”

Between Hannah & Diana it was no competition. Hannah was by a very long way the beter sing. Dianos voice was weak and frequently went off key. I think even she was supprised she was put through.
Beer
05-10-2008
Originally Posted by Off_the_hook13:
“I agree 100%. Ok Alex is good but she isn't outstanding, Hannah was amazing and she isn't exactly your everyday X Factor contestant. You see thousands of the same sort of people with the same voices at the audtions but Hannah was different to a lot of what we've seen before.
Tbh I don't think Cheryl could handle telling Alex she didn't make it for the 2nd time which would have helped influence her decision.

I don't think Simon would have been very pleased when he found out Hannah was turned down, he seemed to really like her and its not often he says someone is "incredible" and "one to watch." I wish Simon had got the girls now cause Hannah would have definately got through.

She would have been a serious contender if she'd got through, even the bookies had her as the favourite at one point and quite a lot of people seem gutted that she didn't get through. Big mistake imo.”

Last year a lot of great people didn't go through for some really bad ones.

This year there were a lot of bad people in the last 24 and all the good ones didn't go through to the final 12.
peaceablegenie2
05-10-2008
gutted for Hannah, she was one of my faves
xBarkateerKimx
05-10-2008
Cant believe it, Hannah was my fave
But the catergory was soo tough, I dont know who should of gone.
Beer
05-10-2008
Originally Posted by xBarkateerKimx:
“Cant believe it, Hannah was my fave
But the catergory was soo tough, I dont know who should of gone.”

I do.

Alexandera
Anastasia
Amy

It was destined to be as their names begin with A. Unfortunately it was not so.
PANNAL1
06-10-2008
Hannah should have been put through in place of Diana, Cheryl made a big mistake there and completely contradicted herself in her decision
twombly
06-10-2008
No way should Alex have gone through. There was nothing special or different about her. Hannah could have easily won the XFactor imo.
Beer
06-10-2008
Originally Posted by twombly:
“No way should Alex have gone through. There was nothing special or different about her. Hannah could have easily won the XFactor imo.”

Thanks and I agree entirely.
caz789
06-10-2008
Disappointed she's not through, it was a really strong category this year, but she's so much more talented than some previous contestants there have been. She'd have been a reliable performer as well.

I don't realistically see how a wildcard would work now, but you never know.

Always next year though I suppose

(EDIT - IMO she should have been through this year)
Beer
06-10-2008
Originally Posted by caz789:
“Disappointed she's not through, it was a really strong category this year, but she's so much more talented than some previous contestants there have been. She'd have been a reliable performer as well.

I don't realistically see how a wildcard would work now, but you never know.

Always next year though I suppose

(EDIT - IMO she should have been through this year)”

I have no idea what this wild card is but it would be fun to find out.
Beer
06-10-2008
Hannah Bradbeer is on This Morning NOW!
caz789
06-10-2008
Originally Posted by Beer:
“I have no idea what this wild card is but it would be fun to find out.”

I've got a suggestion for how it could work - they could put Hannah in now.
As a wildcard. Simple.
I'll contact ITV now with my suggestion.
twombly
06-10-2008
Hannah came across as independant, strong, assertive and very talented which is probably why she didn't go through. The X-Factor is a money making machine, they want people they can manipulate and mould to their own specifications. Hopefully Hannah will be spotted and forge a real singing career away from the sham of reality tv.
Beer
06-10-2008
Originally Posted by caz789:
“I've got a suggestion for how it could work - they could put Hannah in now.
As a wildcard. Simple.
I'll contact ITV now with my suggestion. ”

Yeah just throw her in for the sake of it. That sake being "brilliant singing".
Beer
06-10-2008
Hannah on This Morning

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qGphDUj6HC0
utoia2007
06-10-2008
duplicate
utoia2007
06-10-2008
Originally Posted by Off_the_hook13:
“I agree 100%. Ok Alex is good but she isn't outstanding, Hannah was amazing and she isn't exactly your everyday X Factor contestant. You see thousands of the same sort of people with the same voices at the audtions but Hannah was different to a lot of what we've seen before.
Tbh I don't think Cheryl could handle telling Alex she didn't make it for the 2nd time which would have helped influence her decision.

I don't think Simon would have been very pleased when he found out Hannah was turned down, he seemed to really like her and its not often he says someone is "incredible" and "one to watch." I wish Simon had got the girls now cause Hannah would have definately got through.

She would have been a serious contender if she'd got through, even the bookies had her as the favourite at one point and quite a lot of people seem gutted that she didn't get through. Big mistake imo.”

Completely agree, should have been hannah over dianna. I think they choose dianna to have more variety in the girls. Over wise that would be rachel, laura and hannah who have similar styles which would split the votes.

I like alex, but i agree, i dont think theres anything unique or anything that stands out about her voice, heard it a million times before. Shes technically the most acomplished singer though. But in terms of relevance in the music industry today hannah and laura are streaks ahead.

I dont think hannah will have any problem getting signed, sure theres plenty who want to jump on the winehouse, duffy bandwagon. Shes got an edgy voice and unique style.
mich007
06-10-2008
Originally Posted by utoia2007:
“Completely agree, should have been hannah over dianna. I think they choose dianna to have more variety in the girls. Over wise that would be rachel, laura and hannah who have similar styles which would split the votes.

I like alex, but i agree, i dont think theres anything unique or anything that stands out about her voice, heard it a million times before. Shes technically the most acomplished singer though. But in terms of relevance in the music industry today hannah and laura are streaks ahead.

I dont think hannah will have any problem getting signed, sure theres plenty who want to jump on the winehouse, duffy bandwagon. Shes got an edgy voice and unique style.”

Agree

She was my favourite.

Alex is great though, yeah nothing new but she nailed that Beyonce song singing it better than her.

Hannah would have been my out and out favourite. A naturally talented singer, confident at the mic. I hope by some miracle they find a way to bring her back.

Hannah sings mercy better than Duffy.
<<
<
4 of 5
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map