I think Simon made a mistake putting Scott through , Liam shouldve been there instead


And Susie should be there instead of Daniel


What do you think?

I think Suzy should have been there instead of Rachel.

Dannii made a mistake by putting Daniel through over Suzie.

She claims Suzie doesn't have 'the X factor', but does she honestly think Daniel has it? Come on.

Suzie was miles better, vocally, than Daniel.

IMO Scott was the only one he got right!

I would have put Mali or Liam through instead of Eoin - nice looking boy but I don't think his voice as good as either of the other two yougsters.

They all did apart from the Irishman

Yes Suzie instead of Rachel
Alan instead of the wee irish lad(whose name escapes me)
Hannah instead of the small blone one (whose name also escapes me)

Suzie and Hannah should have got through instead of Daniel and Diana.

I don't really know much about Scott. I don't remember him from the auditions.

Hannah instead of Alex for me. Think Suzy has had her chances and at least Daniels sob story will get him through a few live shows.

Simon by putting red coat through and not Mali

You seemed to remember it long enough to pop into her Appreciation Thread and slag her off

Susie should have gone through in place of Daniel
and I would of liked to see Amy go through to.. but I loved 5 out of the six girls this year

Scott was a shocker for me - very bland. And my favourite Mali rejected - a travesty

If I was Simon I would have put Austin, Mali and Eoghan through though I don't like Austin but you have to go with the best voices. Liam didn't have a bad voice but nothing special to make him stand out from the crowd.

Louis - he got rid of the three sisters and bro. They were fun and cute and entertaining. Instead we've got two boring girl bands.

I feel like he didn't want two black groups to be honest, but we can have two typical run of the mill wannabe girl bands.

One is so boring its even called girl band!!!!

Simon - Eoghan over Mali or Liam
Danii - Daniel instead of Suzie
Louis - I think he made good decisions but had a pretty weak category in the first place
Cheryl - Good decisions, Diana is a bit of a risk, but I think it'll pay off

Cheryl made a HUGE mistake not putting Hannah though, it should have been her instead of Alex.

Agreed

Daniel's terrible

All of them IMO.

To be honest; only thing that annoyed me was Louis sending 4Instinct home and putting the two girl groups through.


Simon made the best of a bad lot really. I don't think it would have made a big impact on the show if he had chosed anyone else.

Same for Cheryl but in reverse; she had 6 good ones. She could have picked any 3 at random and we would have 3 good girls.

Over 25's; are fine really.


Groups; thats where the mess comes in. 2 average girl groups when they had 4instinct; who I think have a lot more potential and were better than the 2 girl groups even on their off-day.

I think Louis made a mistake not putting through the 4 individual lads who'd come together as a band. They weren't the best but they were lookers and that would have counted for a lot in the key voting categories of Girls 'n' Gays.

You can't discount the value of Sugar magazine posters!

Agree with SarahJane though... There was definitely an element of not necessary racism but certainly race-awareness; and I think some acts were negatively affected by an awareness of the judges to be seen (even if they're not) equal to all.

Simon did by not having Mali in there and so did Danni putting Daniel in over Suzie but that's it.

Mali instead of Scott.
Suzie instead of Daniel.

Otherwise I think the final 12 is just right.

Alan or mali instead of scott

Desire or 4 instinct instead of girlband

Suzie instead of daniel

I thought Eoghan and Scott were the weakest of Simon's six so I definitely think he messed up there. I liked Marli and Alan much better. He got Austin right, though.

I didn't agree with choosing Daniel. I would have preferred Suzie or James.

I agree with Louis' choices completely. I particularly like JLS and Bad Lashes.

I agreed with Laura and Alex. Didn't agree with Diana. I would have preferred Amy for the likeability factor or Hannah for the vocals.

Having said that, most of them I was judging on what I heard of the last few songs. I've never heard a complete song from any of them so the judges have a lot more to go on.

Regards

Julian