I think Mali and Liam should have been in instead of Scott and Eoghan.

4Insntinct should have been in instead of Girlband.

I think the right ones went through in the other categories.

Hannah should've made it in the Girls category. I think only one from Laura/Diana should've gone through but not both.

I think 4 Instinct should've gone through over Girl Band.

And Mali should've gone through too. He wouldn't have won but was the best singer in that category by a mile, so he deserved a chance.

Hannah instead of Laura, I don't really get what they see in her, and I find Diana's voice much easier to listen to.

Suzy instead of Daniel, what was she doing!!!!!!!!

Simon well I'm not sure, they all made their mistakes and Louis didn't really need to think past JLS

Maybe thats because he changed his image on the judges suggestion.

Daniel, Eoghan and Scott should NOT be in the 12. Also, Girl Band (though they've only been put through as cannon fodder for the first live show so none of the big acts go out by accident).

Simon should of put Liam through over Eoghan
Louis... 4instinct over JLS
Cheryl... Hannah!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! over diana

I was amazed that Eoghan was judged to be better than Liam and Mali - I thought Liam was the best out of those three. He's got such a strong clear deep voice, whereas Eoghan was very weak and Mali was disappointing as well. I hope Liam will come back next year.

Liam, Amy & Suzie should of been put through.

Scott/Eoghan, Diana & Daniel are weak.

Biggest mistake has been Cheryl putting Diana through and not Amy Connelly. Actually - all 6 girls deserve to be on the live shows but that is another story.
Watching Amy's audition and other performances I reckon she could have won x-factor this year. Alex and Laura are probably the favourites, and are my favourites but just have a feeling that Amy would have been sensational. I think Cheryl was afraid that she might break down during her song in one of the first couple of live shows. If that is so I don't agree. I would imagine that Amy is not a professional singer - just like Leon last year. We are supposed to be looking for a new star who has the x-factor, and that should include novice singers if they have as much talent as Amy does. And anyway - there must be a gap of weeks between what we saw this weekend and the first live show. Cheryl should have been bold - if Danni had this category Amy would be in the last 12.