All in the thread title.

Simon should have put through Liam instead of Eoghan
Louis should have put through 4 Instinct instead of Girl band
Dannii should have put through Susie instead of Daniel

I think the only one to get their category spot on was Cheryl.

Yep, definitely Simon, Yogan shouldn't have gone through.

Cheryl.Hannah should have got through not Diana

Mali should have gone through instead of Austin
Hannah should have gone through instead of Alexendera

There weren't many decent acts in the final 25 anyway.

I think Amy was better than both of them but it was very close and i think there was other things taken into account on taking Diana to the live shows.

Simon shouldn't of put through Eoghan through, Liam or Mali deserved that place not him.
Danni shouldn't have put through that Daniel through, Susie was much better than him.

Simon got it SO wrong for me. Mali and Alan should have got through instead of Austin and Scott. His category is so weak now and his three will be out early.

Austin is so annoying and I'm sick of the tears. it doesn't matter how good his voice is or isn't, he's just not likeable.

Simon doesn't want to get it right.
It is not a coincidence that the girls are much stronger than the boys this year, and that it was the opposite last year.
The boys attract loads of female votes, so they really don't want them too strong if they want the girls to do well.

I can't stand Rachel and I'm gutted they put her through, I mean - how many times did she fluff up??!!

I don't think her voice is that good either, she sounds like she's trying to emulate Amy Winehouse - she is not individual at all and I don't think she will be able to take on lots of different styles of music.

She has an awful attitude as well and I am just waiting for her to fall apart on the live shows - I will be very surprised if she doesn't.

She didn't deserve it, she wasn't professional and its its purely for her sob story.

They all made pretty sound choices IMO - the only ones that didn't get through that I wanted were Alan, Amy and the Family Band - so 9 out of my 12 makes me happy

Although I can see why they didn't put Amy through - the other 3 girls are amazingly strong - she just entered in the wrong year; last year she would have made the top 3 EASILY

Dannii should have put through Louise instead of the horrible Rachel..

And the other guy instead of Daniel

Liam and Mali instead of Eoghan and Scott

Hannah instead of Laura - she's too similar to Diana

Susie instead of Daniel

4instinct instead of Girlband

Yeahh... last year Amy would have definitly made the top three. The girls are so much stronger this year than last...

I think Dannii should have put James through instead of Danny. Danny will never win. James could have been in with a shot.
I think Alan should have gone through instead of Eoghan. I think that if one of the younger lads in Simons group had to go through, then I would have put Eoghan bottom out of the 3. But that said, in a couple of years, Mali will be even better, so maybe Simon sees him as someone to earmark for a future series.
I loved Alan though and was annoyed that he didnt get through

simons made the biggest mistake putting eoghan through-he said himself he wasnt ready and didnt have the strongest voice

it should have been mali- and as much as i think scotts a nice person he doesnt hav the x factor at all

simons lot will be out first

cheryl had some hard decisions i liked hannah but also diana so i dont think its was a mistake she just hd to pick one or another

dannii hadnt got a strong category anyway rachls got a good enough voice but she cant fisnish a song wot is she going to be like live

daniel is just for the symathy vote and ruth is ok a bit emotinal though

for once i think louis made the right choices although i prefer bad lashes to girlband

jls are good

I think Simon got it badly wrong, Austin is good enough but the other 2 are useless. Any 2 of the other guys would have been better.

Alex xhould not have gone through. Cheryl wotsherface got it wrong.

Yes. Hannah was way better.

Simon has got it so wrong this year, I totally agree that Liam should have gone through instead of Eoghan, but I think that Alan should have gone through instead of Scott too, there's only Austin that he got right - although I'm thinking is this a tactical move and he wants Austin to win, therefore take away his main competition which would have been Liam and Alan?

Agree with you about Louis too, should def have been 4Instinct instead of Girlband, they'll go out early.

Sorry, but I like Daniel and I think that was a close call between him and Suzie.

Cheryl got it spot on for me, although I like Amy and Hannah I think she picked the right top 3.

All in all I think it will be a good year this year though having said that, the tour could be good this year too if it goes down to the correct final 8.

Hmm, I'm not sure why Cheryl didtn put Hanna (I think that was her name!) through when she was clearly a good singer? I would have only put either Laura or Diana through not both. Also think Diana oversings a bit.

Simon, I think should have put Liam through instead of Eoghan. Although I liked Alan I could see that he was not a strong enough singer

I understand thats its an emotional time but Austins constant crying gets a bit much!

Danni I think should have out Susie through and I can't remember what her reasons were for not putting her through. I agree with some one else's post who said that Rachel fluffed too many times and keeps getting second chances.

For one I liked all of Louis' choices!

totally aggree she will let danni down

Simon might as well have just picked Austin and had a raffle for the last 2 places. None of the other 5 were going far.

Danni should have picked the pro-golfer guy instead of Danny. Susie was better than Danny, but nothing special and it would have meant 3 women making up the category.

Louis picked the two that he should have with JLS and BadLashes. I'd have taken 4Instinct for something different and to avoid splitting the girl groups votes. But it doesn't really matter.

Cheryl had 2 obvious choices with Alexandra and Laura. She had one big choice between Diana and Hannah and I think she chose the right one, others will disagree. But they are both strong so it shouldn't make much difference. Her best hopes are still the first 2.

I totally agree with everything you say here!