She picked all the wrong ones to go through imho. All she does is sob, drone on in her monotous voice and make stupid decisions! 
What is the point of Cheryl?
1 of 2
Originally Posted by twombly:
“She picked all the wrong ones to go through imho. All she does is sob, drone on in her monotous voice and make stupid decisions!”
“She picked all the wrong ones to go through imho. All she does is sob, drone on in her monotous voice and make stupid decisions!
”
Actually she chose all the RIGHT ones and is the best judge on the show!!
Yeah, I think most people agree that all her three were the right choice, and those who disagree would only swap Diana with Hannah, so it's still 2/3 right.
Originally Posted by mr_scotty2hotty:
“Actually she chose all the RIGHT ones and is the best judge on the show!!”
“Actually she chose all the RIGHT ones and is the best judge on the show!!”
Omg you're so funny, you should be on the stage
Originally Posted by Fenixx:
“Yeah, I think most people agree that all her three were the right choice, and those who disagree would only swap Diana with Hannah, so it's still 2/3 right.”
“Yeah, I think most people agree that all her three were the right choice, and those who disagree would only swap Diana with Hannah, so it's still 2/3 right.”
I would deffo say she chose the correct three. Hannah hasnt the image of a popstar whereas Diana does!!
Originally Posted by twombly:
“Diana was ok but the other two were average
”
“Diana was ok but the other two were average
”
Call me funny and you cant see talent like Alexandra... Average?? Yeah sure!!
Cheryl was the only judge not to be swayed by sob stories. She made the absolute right choices. She's the only Judge who is currently a bona fide chart star and not one of the others can say that.
Originally Posted by twombly:
“Because it made me laugh!”
“Because it made me laugh!”
It was just a nasty spiteful comment. No need!!
She chose the best three imo.
Its good to have her, not only is she in a very successful band so knows the industry, she knows how thw contestants feel.
Its good to have her, not only is she in a very successful band so knows the industry, she knows how thw contestants feel.
Originally Posted by mr_scotty2hotty:
“It was just a nasty spiteful comment. No need!!”
“It was just a nasty spiteful comment. No need!!”
And this comment you made in another thread isn't spitful? -
"Very ugly girl and thats why she wasnt put through cause she did have a good voice... Not the image!!"
You must be an oil painting
Originally Posted by mr_scotty2hotty:
“Call me funny and you cant see talent like Alexandra... Average?? Yeah sure!!”
“Call me funny and you cant see talent like Alexandra... Average?? Yeah sure!!”
Alexandra had nothing unique or different in her voice. She sounded like alot of girls out there churning out the same stuff.
Originally Posted by twombly:
“And this comment you made in another thread isn't spitful? -
"Very ugly girl and thats why she wasnt put through cause she did have a good voice... Not the image!!"
You must be an oil painting”
“And this comment you made in another thread isn't spitful? -
"Very ugly girl and thats why she wasnt put through cause she did have a good voice... Not the image!!"
You must be an oil painting
”
that was not me being horrible at all it is what i think cheryl made her decision on. hence i complimented her voice you moron!!!
Originally Posted by twombly:
“She picked all the wrong ones to go through imho. All she does is sob, drone on in her monotous voice and make stupid decisions!”
“She picked all the wrong ones to go through imho. All she does is sob, drone on in her monotous voice and make stupid decisions!
”
So you would have gone for every one of the other 3?
How unfortunate.
Originally Posted by twombly:
“Alexandra had nothing unique or different in her voice. She sounded like alot of girls out there churning out the same stuff.”
“Alexandra had nothing unique or different in her voice. She sounded like alot of girls out there churning out the same stuff.”
I think Alexandra has an amazing voice but she isn't going to be a lasting pop star. Not many that come from these shows are. I think the same for Laura but I think Diana is amazing and has the potential to make it as big as Leona.
Well, she was hardly going to choose Anastacia was she?!
Or Amy, purely on the strength of her sob story?
So she certainly didn't pick all the wrong ones. The only debate seems to be over Hannah or Diana.
Having picked the favourite to win, she's probably quite happy with her choices.
And apart from that, she's freshened up the show no end. With record ratings this year (11.4 million watched last night), I don't think she's been a bad appointment.
Or Amy, purely on the strength of her sob story?
So she certainly didn't pick all the wrong ones. The only debate seems to be over Hannah or Diana.
Having picked the favourite to win, she's probably quite happy with her choices.
And apart from that, she's freshened up the show no end. With record ratings this year (11.4 million watched last night), I don't think she's been a bad appointment.
Originally Posted by Official Diva:
“I think Alexandra has an amazing voice but she isn't going to be a lasting pop star. Not many that come from these shows are. I think the same for Laura but I think Diana is amazing and has the potential to make it as big as Leona.”
“I think Alexandra has an amazing voice but she isn't going to be a lasting pop star. Not many that come from these shows are. I think the same for Laura but I think Diana is amazing and has the potential to make it as big as Leona.”
See, I cannot see anything in Diana at all. If anyone out of those three is going to have a shot at Leona ville I'd say it's Laura.
I agree re Alexandra, she is excellent but isn't going to get the longevity. A bit like Maria Lawson I think.
Isn't it weird how we all see different things? I don't rate Diana but respect that others like her. I personally think Hannah should have been chosen over her then that category would have been untouchable, in my opinion.
ALEXANDRA is beautiful and talented. Cheryl Cole is beautiful and all her decisions i believe are right.
I think she was spot on.
She had the toughest decision to make since Hannah deserves to be in the live shows more than all the boys, more than Girland or Bad Lashes and more than Rachel and Daniel, yet unfortunately the other 3 girls were just too strong. I would have liked Hannah to make the live shows because her version of Piece of My Heart was outstanding, but Diana's Hallelujah is probably my fave X factor performance ever, Laura is outstanding, and as much as I dislike Alexandra as a person (With her single bed between two and her Blackberry?) her voice is outstanding. I agree with above post about her being a Maria Lawson style contestant rather than Leona. I think Diana with the right songs could easily reach Leona heights, she has a great unique voice in the competition and I think Cheryl will "do a Dannii" and have her two acts in the final 2, with Diana V Laura. (hopefully with Diana winning)
She had the toughest decision to make since Hannah deserves to be in the live shows more than all the boys, more than Girland or Bad Lashes and more than Rachel and Daniel, yet unfortunately the other 3 girls were just too strong. I would have liked Hannah to make the live shows because her version of Piece of My Heart was outstanding, but Diana's Hallelujah is probably my fave X factor performance ever, Laura is outstanding, and as much as I dislike Alexandra as a person (With her single bed between two and her Blackberry?) her voice is outstanding. I agree with above post about her being a Maria Lawson style contestant rather than Leona. I think Diana with the right songs could easily reach Leona heights, she has a great unique voice in the competition and I think Cheryl will "do a Dannii" and have her two acts in the final 2, with Diana V Laura. (hopefully with Diana winning)
I think Cheryl made the right choices. I was glad she wasn't swayed by Amy's sad story because as sad as it was, she wasn't a good enough singer for the live rounds and she would have struggled.
Originally Posted by Cuppa_Tea:
“I think Cheryl made the right choices. I was glad she wasn't swayed by Amy's sad story because as sad as it was, she wasn't a good enough singer for the live rounds and she would have struggled.”
“I think Cheryl made the right choices. I was glad she wasn't swayed by Amy's sad story because as sad as it was, she wasn't a good enough singer for the live rounds and she would have struggled.”
I thought Amy was good enough. The only one i'd say wouldn't stand a chance out of the girls is anastasia. It was just a toughie between the other five imo.
If this wildcard rumour is true then I hope Hannah gets it
alexandra is really good (anyone notice her lips? they r so massive!)
blonde hair girl is good too
the pug nose one (really ugly one) is such a wannabe-she is the only mistake
simon/louis made the worst mistakes
blonde hair girl is good too
the pug nose one (really ugly one) is such a wannabe-she is the only mistake
simon/louis made the worst mistakes
1 of 2
