She made all the right choices, shes one of the best judges. Better than Danii thats for sure.
What is the point of Cheryl?
2 of 2
I wouldn't say she picked the wrong girls, but she picked the safe ones.
There's not much of a challenge there
There's not much of a challenge there
Originally Posted by mr_scotty2hotty:
“Actually she chose all the RIGHT ones and is the best judge on the show!!”
“Actually she chose all the RIGHT ones and is the best judge on the show!!”
agreed
She picked the three with the strongest voices, simple as.
There all amazing
Alex-Brillient, You seriously cannot say she can't sing.
Diana-Shes original-Thats what the xfactors all about.
Laura-Shes pretty different to & her vocal range is amazing! there all really good!
Better choices than Danni & Simon thats for sure.
There all amazing
Alex-Brillient, You seriously cannot say she can't sing.
Diana-Shes original-Thats what the xfactors all about.
Laura-Shes pretty different to & her vocal range is amazing! there all really good!
Better choices than Danni & Simon thats for sure.
Originally Posted by mr_scotty2hotty:
“Actually she chose all the RIGHT ones and is the best judge on the show!!”
“Actually she chose all the RIGHT ones and is the best judge on the show!!”
Exactly! 100% agreed
Originally Posted by vickilou:
“She picked the three with the strongest voices, simple as.
There all amazing
Alex-Brillient, You seriously cannot say she can't sing.
Diana-Shes original-Thats what the xfactors all about.
Laura-Shes pretty different to & her vocal range is amazing! there all really good!
Better choices than Danni & Simon thats for sure.”
“She picked the three with the strongest voices, simple as.
There all amazing
Alex-Brillient, You seriously cannot say she can't sing.
Diana-Shes original-Thats what the xfactors all about.
Laura-Shes pretty different to & her vocal range is amazing! there all really good!
Better choices than Danni & Simon thats for sure.”
And I also agree with you too
Originally Posted by marianner:
“I wouldn't say she picked the wrong girls, but she picked the safe ones.
There's not much of a challenge there”
“I wouldn't say she picked the wrong girls, but she picked the safe ones.
There's not much of a challenge there”
Yes that's very true. No originality there although Diane might have some promise.
Originally Posted by InMyArms:
“Looks like most people disagree with the OP
”
“Looks like most people disagree with the OP
”
I am very happy with that
but i still stick to my original post. 
I think people need to lay off Cheryl now.
She has proved she has what it takes to be a mentor by the people she has picked. I gave my opinions on those three early on in this thread but Cheryl knew what would work and what wouldn't. Amy wouldn't have worked as a popstar and like wise with Hannah. They wouldn't have been able to market her.
Yet Diana - who I think is the winner, Alexandra and Laura do have talent and can be marketed in the industry and that's what it's about.
So to me, and I have voiced doubts in the past. Cheryl has proved herself to be more than capable and is a good addition.
Sharon O would have picked Amy and Hannah instead of Laura and Diana and lost the potential winner and both would have been out early on. Cheryl know's what she is doing.
And I think people need to stop with the Cheryl vs Dannii comments as it just makes them look very young tbh.
She has proved she has what it takes to be a mentor by the people she has picked. I gave my opinions on those three early on in this thread but Cheryl knew what would work and what wouldn't. Amy wouldn't have worked as a popstar and like wise with Hannah. They wouldn't have been able to market her.
Yet Diana - who I think is the winner, Alexandra and Laura do have talent and can be marketed in the industry and that's what it's about.
So to me, and I have voiced doubts in the past. Cheryl has proved herself to be more than capable and is a good addition.
Sharon O would have picked Amy and Hannah instead of Laura and Diana and lost the potential winner and both would have been out early on. Cheryl know's what she is doing.
And I think people need to stop with the Cheryl vs Dannii comments as it just makes them look very young tbh.
Not a huge fan of Cheryl but I think its easy to forget that the girls were easily the best group there.
It was always going to to be Alex v Anastacia, Laura v Hannah and then Diana v Amy.
Personally I would have gone for Amy over Diana as I think Laura and Diana have too similar a look and I personally preferred Amy's voice...to my mind it would have given her 3 very distinct contestants.
I also think Hannah was a better singer than Laura and did far better auditions, but sadly she didn't have the package that Laura had.
All in all I wasn't surprised at who Cheryl picked however and if she could just stop crying so much, I might even like her
It was always going to to be Alex v Anastacia, Laura v Hannah and then Diana v Amy.
Personally I would have gone for Amy over Diana as I think Laura and Diana have too similar a look and I personally preferred Amy's voice...to my mind it would have given her 3 very distinct contestants.
I also think Hannah was a better singer than Laura and did far better auditions, but sadly she didn't have the package that Laura had.
All in all I wasn't surprised at who Cheryl picked however and if she could just stop crying so much, I might even like her
Originally Posted by twombly:
“Diana was ok but the other two were average
”
“Diana was ok but the other two were average
”
I think Alexanra and Laura were good, but Diana is not that good. Hannah or Amy should have went through instead of Diana
Cheryl's point is to give blokes like me who wouldn't dream of watching the show something to look at when their partners force them to. Like Ola on Strictly.
2 of 2
