HI all,

Bit late posting as i was away on hols but I was so annoyed that Louis did not put 4Insticnt through. I would have looked forward to seeing what these guys would have done every week something motownish or you know fun 50s diner type tunes.....i am just so sick of hearing christana/mariah/whitney..rhianna'umbrella'...amy winehouse tracks murdered and all the girls and girl bands will probably doing rounds of these songs every week

I like hearing artists do unusal songs - rock from the 60s 70s, motown, even opera....

I jsut wish they would pick the more unique singers and make the live shows more vaired...it would defiinitely attract more viewers.

I am just sad that 2 girlbands in fairness of the same genre are through when we missed the chance to have a unique act like 4Instinct- i feel the same about Mail in simons group...the butlins guy and the little northern lad are too alike and will do the same boyband cr@p week in week out.

Anyway rant over - does anyone agree /disagree??!!

Because 4Instict wouldnt hold up on the live shows. We saw what happened at bootcamp and besides Bad Lashes haven't chosen conventional choices

I liked them but felt they werent quite ready this year.

i like Bad Lashes and think they deserve to be there as do JLS.

not fussed on Girlband but there cannon fodder anyway.

hopefully 4instinct will return next year.

last year was even worse when Cowell put the vile and talentless Hopeless through before the brilliant I Sette Cantetti.still fuming about that.

I think that Louis put the three best groups through. 4Instinct crumbled at Bootcamp and weren't very good at the judges houses, so I think the live shows would have been too much for them.

I thought they were good at judges houses and Girl Band were absolute sh*te. 4 Instinct were good I thought, I just wouldn't exactly call them original (Motown).

I thought 4Instinct were very good at the judges houses i lived Rockin Robin! I guess i meant original in that....there isn't really anything like them in the charts today and they were just really refreshing!

I mean all acts get makeovers voice coaching from the time they are picked at boot camp ot the live shows - i think 4Instinct were a raw talent in that ...they werent stage school bunnies - with a little voice caoching etc they would have been great and great to watch on the live shows!

They were good but bootcamp showed they need one or two more years to fully mature. I like them but one of the girls got really worked up and angry in their second day bootcamp performance. They can't do that in the middle of a live show song! They have huge potential and I think if they came back in the future, they would stand a great chance of making the live shows and doing well in the competition