You know what, I'll be honest and admit that a girl's looks (which includes her body) is important to me if I am going to be attracted to them. I'm not gonna be attracted to a fat girl or someone with handles hanging over their waistline. Shallow, possibly, but I'm gonna be honest about it. I'm no oil painting and could do with losing a few pounds myself, so I'm probably also a hypocrite. Oh well, such is being human!

Anyway, I wanted to get that said because I never even noticed that these girls would be considered overweight/in need of toning up. I wouldn't descibe them as a "bigger," girl group. They look perfectly fine as they are. Big, they ain't! I mean, I just don't see it at all. They're all slim. They're all in good proportion.

They all look perfectly fine and attractive to me, not even close to being "big" -- from the mouth of an endlessly shallow guy.

this is a really bad thing, to promote the idea that Girlband
are overweight is absolutely ridiculous and irresponsible.

dont we have enough horror stories of anorexia and bulimia
these days.?

there just normal,attractive young girls.one is slightly bigger than the others but not to a very noticeable degree.

i agree there not that great and there cannon fodder but theres nothing wrong with their figures ffs.
not every man wants a stick insect Mr Cowell.

Hi, if Simon told them to *tone up* then it means they don't have the XFactor. You can't manufacture XFactor, it's either you've got it or you haven't, and all the toning up or down won't make any difference at all.