heres a little sort of "game" you guys might enjoy.

If the judges were assigned different categories do you think they would have made different choices to there to top 3?

no need to write down all the possibilities...

I think Hannah would have made it through if it were up danni or louis's.

I think Cheryl may have put Suzie through as well.

and Simon would have almost definately put 4instinct through!

can anyone think of any other possibilities?

I think they would be exactly the same as they were decided before the judges homes round

has this actually been proven? I thought that was just a rumour?

why would simon go through all the trouble of bringing back liam if they weren't gonna put him through to the live shows??? just for good tv??? how low......

I didn't even know it was a rumour I was just being half cynical and half joking. I'm probably right though

I say rumour....I mean someone mentioned it on another thread, most likely yourself. hehehe. I probably should of wrote "theory" as opposed to "rumour" I suppose....

I expect 3 judges got a phone call telling them who was going through.

I may just be cynical but i really don't believe the judges decided individually who would make it through. Im sure the producers decides for them. I would bet on it..

Both Louis and Simon loved Hannah's first performance. Simon had said that Hannah was definitely one to watch and to trust him.
I'm so sorry that hannah isn't in the final with Alex and Laura as she deserved to be. I'm not struck on Diana's voice.

Although simon loved her, I get the feeling he would have choosen diana over hannah :/

Ooh I love it a question that can never be answered. I think the decisions would have been the same. I am inclined to agree with those that say the acts that were put through were decisions made mainly by the producers. Im not sure how much input the judges actually had. difficult one to comment on.

Question to self - If I find it difficult to answer the thread why am I answering it.

Simon---Girls!!

Hannah,
Alexandra,
Diana

Danni--Boys

Eoghann
Austin
Liam

Cheryl--groups

Bad Lashes,
Jls
4 Instictt

Louis--over 25's

Rachel,
Suzie,
Daniel

thats what i think would probs happen

I'll go with the game but I don't think it would have been any different because everything is chosen pre-production.

I think...

Dannii and boys - well in all honesty I think Mali would have figured, Hannah and Susie maybe. The rest were completely hangers on.

The 'judges' dont decide individually, so it wouldnt have mattered who got what category.