• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • The X Factor
Best to worst of tonight
<<
<
2 of 4
>>
>
DeadRinger
11-10-2008
1. Laura
2. Diana
3. Austin
4. Alexandra
5. Ruth
6. Eoghan

I can not rate them anymore, from that point they were all bad and pretty much undistinguishable. Scott was the worse of course.
Like A Star
11-10-2008
1 - Diana (shaky start, amazing towards the end)
2 - Laura (this girl is special)
3 - Eoghan (suprised me)
4 - Girl Band (tbh I'm shocked I'm rating them so highly - thought I'd hate them! )
5 - Ruth (beautiful voice)
6 - JLS (good vocals, boring song)
7 - Alexandra (great voice but I prefer her singing ballads)

And then I thought the rest were awful or boring.
The Spoon
11-10-2008
best? either [one near end that I am too pssd to remember] or the girl with the inspired choice of U2 - I had predicted a u2 penned "nothing compares 2U" for her
worst ? Leon dance-alike...Scott bloody awful
maddy_minx
11-10-2008
Laura
Diana
Alexandra
Rachel
Austin
JLS
Scott
Ruth
Girl Band
Daniel
Eoghan
cultsam
11-10-2008
1. Diana (Cheryl) shone like a star and i think she is potentially the best thing to come out of x factor
2. Alexandra (Cheryl) loved this performace although i think there is more to come
3. Laura (Cheryl) great but her outfit ruined the performance. she looked uncomfortable and not the quirky laura we know
4. Ruth (Dannii) loved ruth, she is amazing to listen to and look at :P
5. JLS (Louis) very good and proved themselves
6. Girl Band (Louis) opened show well, sound vocals
7. Scott (Simon) although his song choice was awful, his vocals were not. I love him and hope simon picks something better :S
8. Eoighan (Simon) liked him more than i expected to but still weak
9. Austin (Simon) something felt wrong about austin's performance but i do think he is great and moments showed this
10. Rachel (Dannii) in my head i thought she would nail the song. awful outfit and performance didn't go well
11. Bad Lashes (Louis) not good and arrogant - right to go out of two bands
12. Daniel (Dannii) can't sing, louis was spot on - should have gone!
Adrian01
11-10-2008
On tonight's performance (NOT MY FAVOURITES OVERALL)

1.Diana
2.Ruth
3.Eoghan
4.JLS

5. Alexandra
6. Girlband
7. Bad Lashes
8. Scott

9. Rachel
10. Laura
11. Austin
12. Daniel
omgwtfbbq
12-10-2008
1. Laura
2. Alexandra
3. Ruth
4. Eoghan
5. JLS
6. Girlband
7. Bad Lashes
8. Austin
9. Diana
10. Daniel
11. Rachel
12. Scott
Magpie11
12-10-2008
Laura
Alex
Diana
JLS
Ruth
Austin
Rachel
Eoghan
GirlBand
Bad Lashes
Scott
Daniel
threecheeses
12-10-2008
1. The 3 girls in any old order are all equally quality depends on musical taste.

2. JlS, Rachel, Ruth.

3. Austin.

That's it the rest were pants apart from Bad Lashes' Wonderwall which would have put them with Austin.
InMyArms
12-10-2008
1, Laura
2, Alex
3, Diana

All brill
humpty dumpty
12-10-2008
Liked
1 Alexandra

Not blown away, but at least a bit original
2 Laura
3 Diana

Mediocre
4 Ruth
5 JLS
6 Rachel
7 Eoghan
8 Austin

Didnīt enjoy
9 Girlband
10 Daniel
11 Bad lashes
12 Scott
PlasticGob
12-10-2008
1. Alexandra
2. JLS
3. Laura
4. Ruth
5. Daniel
6. Bad Lashes
7. Girlband
8. Rachel
9. Austin
10. Eoghan
11. Diana
12. Scott
cctps
12-10-2008
1) Diana
2) Laura
3) Alexandra
4) Ruth
5) Austin
6) JLS
7) Rachel
8) Badlashes
9) Eoghan
10) Girl Band
11) Daniel
12) Scott
Ajay14
12-10-2008
01 Diana
02 Ruth
03 Alexandra
04 Girlband (First one)
05 Austin
06 Laura
07 Scott
08 JLS
09 Rachel
10 Bad Lashes
11 Eoghan
12 Daniel
CaroUK
12-10-2008
1.Diana
2. Ruth
3. Alexandra
4. Laura
5. JLS
6.Girlband
7. Scott
8. Eoghan
9. Austin
10. Rachel
11.Daniel
12.Bad Lashes
basdfg
12-10-2008
Good
1- Alexandra( Fantastic My Favorite)
2- Laura(Excellent Voice Need to be more more modern songs)
3- Eoghan( Excellent Voice But i dont think we have seen the best form him)
4- Austin(Great Voice too nervous)
5- JLS( Got more to come)
OK
6- Daniel( Nice Song But Vocals need to be better)
7- Ruth( Dont Keep singing parts in Spanish)
8- Diana( Dont see why every one likes her Bit old fashioned for me)
9- Bad Lashes( Should have stayed )
Bad
10- Scott( Wrong Song )
11- Girlband( Not the Best Vocals )
Dreadful
12- Rachel( Awful Costume and Song)
Imogen M
12-10-2008
Edit - this was meant to be a new thread, pleased ignore.
marsha_Cutiepie
12-10-2008
Mine are

1. Diana.....I love her - she is just so uniqiue and her voice is melting, my fave at the moment

2. Alex ... did a great job and what a dancer!

3. Eoghan...by far the best male performance of the night, so confident and assured - i thought he was great!

4. JLS....best group of the night by a mile, these guys will only get better

5. Laura .... i can see Laura has a great range vocally but i am just not into her shouty voice, i think she could get boring

6. Rachel...i thought she was very collected and confident, it was just a bad song, i think when she gets a good song, she will be amazing

7. Ruth....defiintely very sexy! i find her interesting so would like her to stay for a while.

The rest were bad..

8. Girlband - sung well but oh so forgettable

9. Bad Lashes - awful song but shame they went as they deffo had more future potential

10. Daniel - he peformed the song ok, but just very bland

11. Scott - Awful awful song choice, he is very cute and has a good voice, i think he will do better

12. Austin - He was so nervous, out of tune and just painful, i know he cna do better but last night he was terrible
Willz
12-10-2008
On last nights performance it would have to be

Alexandra
Laura
Ruth
Diana
Austin
JLS
Eoghan
Rachel
Girl Band
Daniel
Scott
Chapman
12-10-2008
1. Laura
2. Diana
3. Alexandra
4. Ruth
5. JLS
6. Eoghan
7. Rachel
8. Austin
9. BadLashes
10. Girlband
11. Daniel
12. Scott

tellmeall
12-10-2008
Best and talented:
1. Alexandra
2.Laura
3.JLS
4.Rachel

The middle players:
5. Scott
6.Diana
7.Ruth
8. Austin
9. Girlband


Piss poor, bin them:
Eoghan
Daniel
Foxy Moron
12-10-2008
1. Laura
2. Alexandra
3. Diana
4. Eoghan
5. Austin
6. JLS
7. Ruth
8. Rachel
9. BadLashes
10. Girlband
11. Scott
12. Daniel
CassTrelawney
12-10-2008
Best to worst..

1- Diana
2- Laura (really close between the first two)
3- JLS
4- Bad Lashes
5- Girlband
6- Rachel
7- Ruth
8- Alexandra
9- Austin
10- Eoghan
11- Daniel
12- Scott

TotalShopaholic
12-10-2008
Top 5:
1. Alexandra- Had the whole package sang well, danced well and looked great
2. Laura
3. Diana- Pleasantly surprsied, wasn't that keen on her before. Only thing that let her down were the forced looking hand movements.
4. Ruth.
5. JLS- Really impressed me! I think they have a great connection.

Bottom 3
10. Scott- wasn't his fault but SUCH a terrible song choice.
11. Bad Lashes- Some of those harmonies were painful.
12. Daniel- Average at best.

The rest were ok.
Tajiri
12-10-2008
Eoghan
Laura
Austin
Rachel
JLS
Diana
Ruth
Alex
Scott
Girl Band
Daniel
Bad Lashes
<<
<
2 of 4
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map