Surely the judges are aware of their poor song choices before the show?

2 of 2

thenetworkbabe

13-10-2008

Originally Posted by katiemack:
“Too true i think the mentors should suggest 3 songs to them and they should pick there fave AND they should speak up but saying that rachel did but danni went with it but you could see in rachel's performance that dannii herself knew it was not that good and i believe that was the only reason she stood up and clapped as kind of a way of apology if that makes any sense...”

Or even have a quick run through of 3 to see which sounds best?

x-xLizx-x

13-10-2008

Does anyone know the link of a YouTube video with Paula accidently giving the comments before performance ?

caz789

13-10-2008

I'm sure there's better ones than this but it starts on here at about 1:45.

http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=hEKIcGVZWoE

PigsMightFly

13-10-2008

I really think that judges shouldn't dictate what their acts should sing without any say so from the acts themselves - they should work together with the acts to find a song that both judge and act are comfortable with.

Of course you don't know how much interaction during the week the judges have with their acts - it seems quite a lot in some cases and very little in others.

2 of 2