I know this is'nt going to happen but I think it would be soooo cool!

Ruth
Diana
Alex
Laura
Rachel for the final 5!

They are all better then all the boys with the possible exception of Austin

It would be unfair for any of them to go out over Eggnog or Daneil

I would love to see it happen, but only if Diana wasn't there and JLS were.

(which wouldn't make it an all girl final five, but meh)

That would be amazing, with Alexandra Winning. American Idol season 3 the final 4 were all female, so it's possible.

Nah it would be boring. Im sure the men would like it though lmaoo.

Diana, Laura, Eoghan, Ruth and Austin would be perfect for me! In that order.

The UK audience would never stand for it.

If you look at all the finalists we have had:

13 males
2 females (one part of a mixed gender duo)

As your title says, you're right, we should do.
I can't see it happening though. Either Austin or Eoghan are going to slip there way into it, I'm sure..
Grr.

Or JLS. Although I wouldn't mind if they were there, so long as they don't take the place of my favourites lol.

Damn straight that should happen but it won't. The question is what wonderful women are we gonna lose early? I think it's safe to say though that it looks like Daniel will be going tonight.

It's terrible really. We have five incredible women but we just know some of them are gonna leave before Eoghan *shivers* :sleep:

Too be honest i don't want an all girl final. I want Austin to be in the final.

2?! Is that all?

That's ridiculous.

I so want a a femal final 5 that would be wicked, they are better then the guys anyway. But the teenage girls (well most) wouldn't stand for it

where did you get that from? mix gender? does it include Big Brother? and are you referring to winners and not finalists?

On all voting reality shows there have been more female winners.. Singing reality shows only Leona Lewis, Michelle Mcmanus, Alex Sparks off fame academy!

I think we do have a very good chance for two ladies in the top 3 though

X factor finalists

Definitely. All the girls are a million times better than the boys. But it won't happen. The producers won't have it

X Factor finalists.

Speaking of Big Brother there's only been three female winners out of nine.

I'm talking about X Factor finalists. Leona and Sarah from male/female duo Same Difference are the only female vocalists to ever make the final.

Simon knows most or alot of phone votes are from young people, teenage girls etc. If it was an all girl final I don't think there would be as many votes and we all know votes = money.

There has been at least one women in every final though

There were NO female finalists in the first 2 series of x factor
and Leona was the last girl standing for quite along time if I remember

I'd be brilliant, and it won't happen, but wouldn't it be lovely if the tweeny girl vote that usually goes to the Ray Quinn-esque contestant goes to Diana this year? That's the beauty of her; she's marmite, but she still appeals to pretty much every age group in some shape or form.

Even then one of those women used to be a man.

Should be an all-girl top 3 atleast. Not gonna happen though

Either way though, I still think one of the girls will win this year.

Final five should be
Diana, Ruth, Rachel, Austin and Daniel.

Alexandra and Laura are too common.

Based on talent it should be an all girl final because Diana, Laura, Ruth, Rachel and Alex are outstanding. But of course we live in a country where the majority of voters are female and we can't vote based on talent alone now can we?