Originally Posted by Harry-Haddock:
“i would so like to do something to that hand of hers!!!!!”
“i would so like to do something to that hand of hers!!!!!”
chop it off and slap her with it?
Diana Vickers Given All Clear To Sing...
2 of 5
Originally Posted by mrs_emily:
“chop it off and slap her with it?”
“chop it off and slap her with it?”
You'd like to chop Diana's hand off?
Originally Posted by xTonix:
“She had it Wednesday/Thursday wasn't it? tis now Tuesday, so that's about 6/7.”
“She had it Wednesday/Thursday wasn't it? tis now Tuesday, so that's about 6/7.”
Well we know in reality she was fine on Wednesday November 5th.... as she was screaming and shouting in the cold and watching fireworks.
So it started on the 6th...and she was given the all clear sometime yesterday ...the 10th. So 4 full days in total....and less than 48 hrs after she was told she couldn't sing.
Originally Posted by Callous:
“Well we know in reality she was fine on Wednesday November 5th.... as she was screaming and shouting in the cold and watching fireworks.
So it started on the 6th...and she was given the all clear sometime yesterday ...the 10th. So 4 full days in total....and less than 48 hrs after she was told she couldn't sing.”
“Well we know in reality she was fine on Wednesday November 5th.... as she was screaming and shouting in the cold and watching fireworks.
So it started on the 6th...and she was given the all clear sometime yesterday ...the 10th. So 4 full days in total....and less than 48 hrs after she was told she couldn't sing.”
Do we know 100% for defo that they were out on Wednesday?
Originally Posted by Callous:
“Well we know in reality she was fine on Wednesday November 5th.... as she was screaming and shouting in the cold and watching fireworks.
So it started on the 6th...and she was given the all clear sometime yesterday ...the 10th. So 4 full days in total....and less than 48 hrs after she was told she couldn't sing.”
“Well we know in reality she was fine on Wednesday November 5th.... as she was screaming and shouting in the cold and watching fireworks.
So it started on the 6th...and she was given the all clear sometime yesterday ...the 10th. So 4 full days in total....and less than 48 hrs after she was told she couldn't sing.”
How do we know that the fire works display was actually on Nov 5th... surely there would've been displays all last week that the finalists could've gone too
Originally Posted by Sib69:
“as much as i dont like her, the show was quite dull without her this week, so am glad she is back”
“as much as i dont like her, the show was quite dull without her this week, so am glad she is back”
I think that had more to do with the Theme and Mariah Dreary's performances
Originally Posted by yohinnchild:
“How do we know that the fire works display was actually on Nov 5th... surely there would've been displays all last week that the finalists could've gone too”
“How do we know that the fire works display was actually on Nov 5th... surely there would've been displays all last week that the finalists could've gone too”
Well it says on the official website that they went out on November 5th for bonfire night.
http://xfactor.itv.com/videos/video-...tem_200465.htm
Yes we have! posted a while ago in another thread
Sparks fly at X Factor celebrity appearance at Rudolph Steiner School in Kings Langley
http://www.watfordobserver.co.uk/new...ty_appearance/
Advert of the Rudolph Steiner School in Kings Langley bonfire party
http://klsteinerfundraiser.com/
Exclusive youtube footage
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jPcT-zO1KEQ
Sparks fly at X Factor celebrity appearance at Rudolph Steiner School in Kings Langley
http://www.watfordobserver.co.uk/new...ty_appearance/
Advert of the Rudolph Steiner School in Kings Langley bonfire party
http://klsteinerfundraiser.com/
Exclusive youtube footage
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jPcT-zO1KEQ
Originally Posted by xTonix:
“Do we know 100% for defo that they were out on Wednesday?”
“Do we know 100% for defo that they were out on Wednesday?”
It takes 2-5 days usually for Laryngitis to clear up, if she was diagnosed on thursday with it, she wouldn't have recovered until today (In fact I'll go so far as to say that the Mirror Article is BS and going on the same hunches we are going on) She won't be able to start practising her next song until thursday at the latest just to make sure she is fully recovered from it.
However, I'm not going to pin all my hopes on a tabloid article at all at the moment, but continue to hope she makes it for Saturday's show.
However, I'm not going to pin all my hopes on a tabloid article at all at the moment, but continue to hope she makes it for Saturday's show.
Originally Posted by yohinnchild:
“How do we know that the fire works display was actually on Nov 5th... surely there would've been displays all last week that the finalists could've gone too”
“How do we know that the fire works display was actually on Nov 5th... surely there would've been displays all last week that the finalists could've gone too”
They was plenty of evidence on here the other day that it was on Wednesday, From flyers for the bonfire to the school website off where it was.etc
Originally Posted by hitnmix:
“They was plenty of evidence on here the other day that it was on Wednesday, From flyers for the bonfire to the school website off where it was.etc”
“They was plenty of evidence on here the other day that it was on Wednesday, From flyers for the bonfire to the school website off where it was.etc”
Exactly, which completely crushes some claims on here as she wouldn't know she had laryngitis until she was diagnosed with it. (OnThursday)
Originally Posted by xTonix:
“Do we know 100% for defo that they were out on Wednesday?”
“Do we know 100% for defo that they were out on Wednesday?”
Here she is with her boyfriend as well
http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage...cle1900491.ece
Article dated the 6th so presumably "last night" was the 5th, 4th at the earliest. She doesn't look ill.
I feel duped.
Originally Posted by caz789:
“ She doesn't look ill.”
“ She doesn't look ill.”
You have your symptoms of Laryngitis mixed up with something else then. Did she have a cold? No. Was she nauseous? No. Did she have a headache? No.
She didn't get really ill to Thursday, the most you can blame her for is going out with what she thought was a cold
Originally Posted by Neit:
“Exactly, which completely crushes some claims on here as she wouldn't know she had laryngitis until she was diagnosed with it. (OnThursday)”
“Exactly, which completely crushes some claims on here as she wouldn't know she had laryngitis until she was diagnosed with it. (OnThursday)”
She must have known she was ill though. In the VT she had apparently been ill all week, hadn't been able to practice her song, pictures of her on her deathbed. Surely you don't go from screaming to voiceless overnight. Looks like a load of lies to me.
Originally Posted by caz789:
“She must have known she was ill though. In the VT she had apparently been ill all week, hadn't been able to practice her song, pictures of her on her deathbed. Surely you don't go from screaming to voiceless overnight. Looks like a load of lies to me.”
“She must have known she was ill though. In the VT she had apparently been ill all week, hadn't been able to practice her song, pictures of her on her deathbed. Surely you don't go from screaming to voiceless overnight. Looks like a load of lies to me.”
I've seen the bonfire footage and perhaps Diana didn't know she had Laryngitis but thought she might have a cough? We don't know, we can't just jump to conclusions. The one thing I'll give you is her being out in the cold if she was ill but another article states she has been to bonfire nights every year since she was little, a foolish thing to do but it is not surprising that she wants to go out and have fun with her new found fame and friends.
Originally Posted by Bob22A:
“Amazing given Laryngitus takes at minimum 7 days to recover from.”
“Amazing given Laryngitus takes at minimum 7 days to recover from.”
Christina Aguilera was singing within 4 days of getting it.
Unless you think she is a liar too.
I forgot your a doctor.
Originally Posted by Neit:
“I've seen the bonfire footage and perhaps Diana didn't know she had Laryngitis but thought she might have a cough? We don't know, we can't just jump to conclusions. The one thing I'll give you is her being out in the cold if she was ill but another article states she has been to bonfire nights every year since she was little, a foolish thing to do but it is not surprising that she wants to go out and have fun with her new found fame and friends.”
“I've seen the bonfire footage and perhaps Diana didn't know she had Laryngitis but thought she might have a cough? We don't know, we can't just jump to conclusions. The one thing I'll give you is her being out in the cold if she was ill but another article states she has been to bonfire nights every year since she was little, a foolish thing to do but it is not surprising that she wants to go out and have fun with her new found fame and friends.”
If you have laringitus you would no. Its not a cold anddos not clear up quickly
So she pulled a sicky to miss a week she could not cope with. Not impressive is it?
Originally Posted by caz789:
“presumably..”
“presumably..”
I'd also just like to emphasise on this, you are just making presumptions, as am I, we don't know the full story and it is unfair to chastise her unless someone comes forward (Diana herself maybe) and explains day by day what happened.
Originally Posted by Neit:
“I've seen the bonfire footage and perhaps Diana didn't know she had Laryngitis but thought she might have a cough? We don't know, we can't just jump to conclusions. The one thing I'll give you is her being out in the cold if she was ill but another article states she has been to bonfire nights every year since she was little, a foolish thing to do but it is not surprising that she wants to go out and have fun with her new found fame and friends.”
“I've seen the bonfire footage and perhaps Diana didn't know she had Laryngitis but thought she might have a cough? We don't know, we can't just jump to conclusions. The one thing I'll give you is her being out in the cold if she was ill but another article states she has been to bonfire nights every year since she was little, a foolish thing to do but it is not surprising that she wants to go out and have fun with her new found fame and friends.”
Yes, I can understand she's young and enjoying herself, and I don't know what else they could have done on the Saturday, but it's still annoying.
Originally Posted by Neit:
“I'd also just like to emphasise on this, you are just making presumptions, as am I, we don't know the full story and it is unfair to chastise her unless someone comes forward (Diana herself maybe) and explains day by day what happened.”
“I'd also just like to emphasise on this, you are just making presumptions, as am I, we don't know the full story and it is unfair to chastise her unless someone comes forward (Diana herself maybe) and explains day by day what happened.”
All I know is that I'd take the word of a real Harley Street doctor over anyone on this forum.
Plently singers have had it and been back on stage within the week.
Some honestly don't seem to know what they talk about. Madonna normally gets it every world tour.
2 of 5
