Originally Posted by johartuk:
“See, I disagree there - yes they have tuning problems as individuals, but at least when they're singing together it doesn't stand out as much, because all the voices are working together rather than individually (so covering up the more glaring tuning problems).
The other thing about Phoebe's voice that I don't like is its harshness - I understand why it's that way (she's young and doesn't have the power or control in her voice yet that you need to be a professional performer, so she makes up for it by shouting).”
I'm afraid it stands out much more for me when they try and sing together

Partly because their voices don't sound as if they're "working together" for me - just sounds like 5 people singing at the same time.