• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Strictly Come Dancing
Poll: the eviction of judges
soulmate61
25-11-2008
"A poor dancer should step aside for a better dancer," said the Righteous Four.

Should a poor judge step aside for a better judge?

Your marks please - 1-5 for eviction, 6-10 invited back for SCD7. Equal marks, for a dance-off.

- Len
- Craig
- Arlene
- Bruno
Jan2555*GG*
25-11-2008
- Len 4
- Craig 6
- Arlene 1
- Bruno 6

Think I have understood !!!!!

I want Arlene to definately GO Len to possibly GO Craig and Bruno I am reasonably happy to stay.
cobaltmale
25-11-2008
I vote soulmate61 be evicted .

Ridiculous idea.

G
reginald1981
25-11-2008
Len 1
Bruno 3
Arlene 8
Craig 9
ealingkid
25-11-2008
Len - 2 - (Boring, grumpy, predictable)
Craig - 9 - (Incisive comments, the best judge)
Arlene - 3 - (Worst culprit in JS debacle. Hate the way she letches over male contestants. A man wouldnt get away with what she does)
Bruno - 7 - (Entertaining. Adds some laughs)
kwscott
25-11-2008
id give all 4 judges 7 they all have good and bad points but i dont want any of them to leave
Mrs F
25-11-2008
Originally Posted by ealingkid:
“Len - 2 - (Boring, grumpy, predictable)
Craig - 9 - (Incisive comments, the best judge)
Arlene - 3 - (Worst culprit in JS debacle. Hate the way she letches over male contestants. A man wouldnt get away with what she does)
Bruno - 7 - (Entertaining. Adds some laughs)”

agree broadly with this.

This season Bruno has been more reasoned with his marking.

Len is increasingly losing the plot, mind you if he went how would they fill all those ITT hours

My vote for elimination is Len and Arlene, who is just plain nasty.
CASPER1066
25-11-2008
Originally Posted by ealingkid:
“Len - 2 - (Boring, grumpy, predictable)
Craig - 7 - (can be incisive comments, )
Arlene - 3 - (Worst culprit in JS debacle. Hate the way she letches over male contestants. A man wouldnt get away with what she does)
Bruno - 7 - (Entertaining. Adds some laughs)”

My changes.
kitana
25-11-2008
Len 3 len, as he would say gets on my wick , never consistant with his markings
Bruno 2 don't like the way he keeps interupting craig, very arrogant
Arlene7 sometimes fair, but does go off on one occassionally
Craig 8 probably the most fair judge, even though he marks low.
bevey
25-11-2008
I dont want any of them to go.
L
bevey
25-11-2008
I dont want any of them to go.
L
bevey
25-11-2008
A[ologies for double post.

I dont want any of them to go.

Len at least gives couples something to work on.
Craig marks low is generally right but sometimes just marks too low.
Bruno - no fun without him!
Arlene well the show wouldnt be the same.

Leave them all well alone!!!
memmh
25-11-2008
Originally Posted by ealingkid:
“Len - 2 - (Boring, grumpy, predictable)
Craig - 9 - (Incisive comments, the best judge)
Arlene - 3 - (Worst culprit in JS debacle. Hate the way she letches over male contestants. A man wouldnt get away with what she does)
Bruno - 7 - (Entertaining. Adds some laughs)”

I agree with your comments but I'd make a few minor changes to the numbers, so:

CRAIG - 7
ARLENE - 4
LEN - 4
BRUNO - 7

I never used to like Craig but I've noticed in the past few weeks that while his comments on each performance usually begin with criticism, he nearly always adds a positive comment or two at the end, which the other judges don't all make a point of doing.

I respect Arlene as a choreographer. I don't like her as a judge. She's coming across as very unpleasant these days.

I've completely lost whatever respect I previously had for Len. The way he lost his temper with Craig this week was completely unprofessional and absolutely uncalled for.

Bruno's been hilarious this series. A welcome bit of light relief after the unpleasantness of the other judges.

Tbh, after the whole insanity that was Sergeantgate, I wouldn't object too strenuously if none of them came back but I wouldn't really have a problem if they all came back. I'm not sure how well replacing any of the judges would work out.
allisonbm2
25-11-2008
Len 2- up himself
Arlene 4 - lusts after the fit blokes too much
Bruno 6 - mad as a box of frogs
Craig 9- I like him can't help it
Strictly Autumn
25-11-2008
Craig 10
Arlene 2
Len 4
Bruno 10

Wiz Net
25-11-2008
Craig - 1 (if I had a zero I would give it to him)
Len - 1
Arlene - 1
Bruno - 8 (he gets two extra marks for shaking his booty with Lisa on the Sunday show!)
Saturn
25-11-2008
1 - Len
10 - Craig
6 - Arlene
8 - Bruno
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map