Got to say she was looking stunning on Saturdays show also on the 1st week of live shows with the blue shirt/dress thing! I really like her on the panel at the moment think she gives good [i][constructive/I] feedback compared to Louis saying to everyone they should be in the final Cheryl smiling and saying something nice and Simon looking very plastic and blowing his own trumpet! - Would like to know wat other people think of her and the Big Question Will She be bck next Year? I hope to god she is also does anyone have any hard evidence that she wont????

There is a Dannii Minogue appreciation thread in here.

But I agree. The woman is a class act.

I already know that - but this is different as its about her coming back or not!

She's the most gorgeous woman, she gives spot on feedback and very constructive critisism.
I LOVE her dresses and shoes!

Simon has been a real bore, Cheryl is OK but nothing special and Louis is a snake.

If she comes back I'll watch it, if she doesn't then I'm going to see her where ever she will go.

Of course she should be back. She's the best judge on the panel.

I'm less keen, i think she comes across as a bit pointless and one dimensional

Not a bit like the others then.

Dannii is the only one who seems to give critical analysis. Remember it was Dannii that first picked up Diana's famous 'claw' hand in week 1. It took weeks for everyone else to notice it.

Yeah, I do remember. Not only is she ubercool... she can also detect annoying habits before Heat Magazine make it their mission to try and find something hilarious in it.

she is a good judge, they need to get rid of the little louis fella.

can't stand her to be honest, think she comes across as fake. I don't think she adds anything to the show.

Totally disagree compared to the other judges she is like goldust. . .

I think there's an element of fakery in all of them to greater or lesser degrees.
But I think she's the best of the four, and in my opinion, the only one who gives her acts, rather than herself, the credit.
Also, when talking to the other acts, she gives feedback on their performance without getting in a sly dig at whoever is mentoring them...unlike the others on the panel.

I love Danni, she is honest and gives constructive feedback. Unlike Cheryl, when Dannii sheds a tear you can see it's genuine.

She seems to spend a lot more time with her acts then any of the other judges. I hope she's back next year.

I also hope Cheryl won't, but I'm afraid that that's unlikely.

She give much more constructive criticism than the others and is always spot on with her analysis. Cheryl on the other hand, being put on the pedestal she does NOT deserve, with love for everyone and pathetic attempts at criticism. Cheryl is just another Sharon, pointless.

Have you noticed Cheryl is in a very lucky position on the panel. She can weigh up the mood of the audience with what Dannii says first then she gets to disagree with her and become the audience hero.