If you had to choose between them would you choose for Hayley or Nicole to return to SCD next year? Or neither? You can't say both! Well, you can but I'm just trying to see who people like better.

I'd definitely pick Hayley. Loved some of her routines. I just wish they had been danced better by Mark.

neither of them. I didnt notice Nicole leaving and i wouldnt notice hayley going.

Nicole has a slight edge over Hayley for me. I wouldn't mind either of them returning, but equally, I wouldn't mind if neither were to return. Given the right partner, they could both make a stamp on the show, though.

Definitely Nicole.

For many reasons but the main one is she can actually dance!

I'd prefer to see Nicole return- the series missed her this year

Hayley. Nicole got up my nose!

Well to be fair, it was very rare that Nicole got very far anyway, so I didnt notice her as much as some of the others.

But I liked her, and I do like Hayley though im not overly bothered.

They could both come or go - I wouldnt mind either way on both of them!

Hayley. I don't think she's had a chance to really prove herself yet.

Nicole!!!

Neither has made a big impression on me but if it had to be one I think Hayley should be given a second chance. No offence to Mark but I'd like to see her with somebody who has a little more dancing ability.

Nicole - her dancing is far superior

Nicole, only because she has strength in both the ballroom and latin whereas if you watch the pro latin dances with Hayley it's obvious it's not her forte.

This is such an easy one for me; Nicole! Hayley was really disappointing, she looked really out of place dancing with the other pros this year.

Nicole, but I rather she replaced Ola than Hayley.

Hayley, she didnt wow me this year but I think she should be given another chance to impress. Although I was sad for Nicole to be sacked, she didnt get very far with any of her celebs so I think really she has had her chance, and anyway I cant see her being asked back.

For definite, Hayley .

I didn't notice Nicole at all, and I cannot remember one routine of her's.

Hayley is a fresh, new face, and I loved some of the routines and choreography she created for Mark. Plus, I don't think we have seen the best of her yet, and her personality hasn't had chance to fully show.

Nicole. She shone in the pro dances.

Nicole

Nicole. She's one of the best and most successful dancers to have represented England over the last few years. Feels wrong to see how she's been treated and she hasn't had a chance to show half of what she can do. Really missed her dancing with Matt in the pro dances.

Hayley. Something about Nicole got up my nose. Not sure what, just one of those things.

Hayley deserves another chance to prove herself with a more capable partner.

Nicole never made much impact with me, I have to say. To be a good Strictly pro you not only have to be an excellent dancer - which Nicole obviously is - but also have a number of other attributes including a televisual personality, which is where I thought Nicole was slightly lacking.

Nicole on merit.
Camilla was given Gethin and Tom, and eventually won.
Give Nicole a chance.

Nicole please

Nicole

Neither of them