I'd have voted for Jason. He may not say things in the nicest way but he ALWAYS has a point and gives ways in which a skater can improve. I'm sick to death of all the pantomine booing and the enormous amount of stick Holly and Phillip give to Jason before he's even said anything.

IMO DoI would be a poorer show without him.

Indeed, the booing is annoying. But Craig from SCD gets it too!

Okay.. So only 20 people voted in this thread? Or 52?

20 and in the other one 32

Oh, okay .

Jason for me.

Would have been Karen for me.

Karen has always been my favourite judge, because although some people criticize her for being too "involved" I like to hear her opinions because; she knows what they've been working on, what their strengths were and where they needed to improve. She sort of knows their particular targets and if they've met them.

I also really like Robin because he gives good advice to the skaters & things to improve on, and he's fair with everyone.

If I had have spotted the poll earlier it would definetely have been Karen for me though