Seriousley how much of a bitch was she to Nicky then?

What the **** does she know about skating? She has no clue what she's talking about. Which is obvious from her scoring. Nicky is however a trained ice dancer.

So shut your fat cakehole in future love and keep you stupid opinions to yourself!!!!!

So you think that Coleen deserved a 4.5, Nicky is ridiculous.

Colleen didn't deserve a 4.5 for her routine, but she was alot better than last week

She had no right to speak to him like that. She came across as a rude, patronising and condesending piece of work. Carrying it over to Ray's peformance was bang out of order.I am still trying to work out why she is on this programme? She has no skating experience and Jason is already there as the dance expert.

What other Judgaes choose to give, is nothing to do with ruthie

Shes eye candy

For elderly men?

Maybe he did mark her a bit high, but he's obviously marking high to make up for the other two non-skating, numpties marking too low.

Right ! I'm off to watch Larkrise now.

Whether she deserved a 4.5 was incidental. The fact was Coleen had finished her routine and had been marked. To regurgitate her performance and do a post mortem on her score after more than one skater had followed was wrong. And what is more if a person felt that the score was valid because they enjoyed the routine then that is their opinion and it should be respected. What makes Ruthie Fri*gging Henshaw so qualified as a judge in any case? When I saw her in a show in London I thought she was sh*te, but that was just me, the audience loved her. And I am not qualified to critique her either..........
I personally think she was being a bitch cos she mentioned Col over the next two danced, I hope she gets a roasting by the producers.

Scary more like.

I agree wih the OP, why go on and on and on about it?

But should he do this anyway, he is professional and should mark as such. He should mark on what he sees. It just makes a mockery of the programme IMO. Coleen already has the public on her side, she doesn't need extra help from the judges.

Ruthie should have shut up and left Nicky alone

Why did they get rid of Krez and Natalia? Ruthie is utterly clueless and is obviousley trying to be the Arlene Phillips of DOI. The problem is Arlene is a dance expert, but Ruthie is not a skating expert.

er what about jason and ruthies ridiculous scores to Zoe.
I like Zoe but she made a huge error and her marks were shokingly high.
Ruthie should just shut up, it was extremely rude her condescending Nicky like that, most the time her marks are pathetic herself.

I don't particularly like Ruthie either but it is not fair to Ray and Jessica, who IMO were both streets ahead of Colleen tonight. 4.5 was ludicrous for her performance.

Then why did she not have a dig at Jason over the last couple of years for his CLEARLY downsizing of people's votes? If she thinks a routine is crap she is entitled to say so. However if someone else thinks it is great then so have they. People should be able to voice an opinion without being castigated by a worn out west end non entity. (My opinion)

You are obviously biased against Ruthie, she was giving her opinion against an absolutely scandalous mark for Coleen.

No I am not biased against ANYONE. I am biased against her RUDE comments to Nicky and her BIAS bringing Coleen up TWICE. And incedentally Coleen didn't only pick up good marks from Nicky but from a couple of the others.

Bit she is only a singer, Nicky should know better, no way was Colleen skate worth 2.5, never mind 4.5.

Its not the point though. It was not the time or the place to do it. She was bang out of order, even Jason is not that unprofessional.

Well you did call her a worn out West End non-entity? IMO they all overmarked Colleen.

But the rest of the judges are always having a pop at Jason

It seems a bit hypocrital when she then goes and overmarks Zoe for tripping up and "recovering" (but still wobbling around like a jelly). If she's going to be mean with her marks, fine, but at least be consistent or have the good grace shut up about what the others do.

This isn't even about Nicky giving high scores, it's about the gobby cow banging on about it.

That's HIS opinion is ENTITLED to it. If not there is no contest. She is not however entitled to bulldoze her way through his opinion and comments TWICE. She is pig ignorant in this case. Downright Rude. You didn't seem to like me commenting negatively on her comments, what we have here is clearly the same as what is going on in the studio. Because someone is slagging off Ruthie you don't like it. Neither do people like it when she slags people off twice and interrups a judges comments and rebukes him for his scoring this would be an OUTRAGE in a normal competition. She was out of order, and if she wasn't why did someone start this thread?