I pinched this idea from the radio station I listen to and used it on the SCD Beeb boards with great success. So let's see if it works as well over here...

All you have to do is rate and slate something to do with DOI. It can be anything - a person, a costume, a judge.

I'll start the ball rolling.

Rated - Todd Carty's routine last night for sheer entertainment value.

Slated - Jeremy and partner's lime green costumes!Especially those boots!

Over to you guys.

Hi all

Rated - Donal practicing in every country that he's been to
Slated - The eye makeup this season

Rated - Ray a great routine... but I don't like the cocky chappie.
Slated- the judges for overmarking Coleen and Stuart, they were never a half point better than Zoe and Matt.

Rated - lovely and kind Karen Barber, whenever she gets a chance to speak
Slated - "performance expert" Ruthie interrupting Nicky

Rated - Gorgeous Frankie in her sexy green dress
Slated - Gorgeous Frankie in hot pants

Rated - Jason giving praise where there has been improvement
Slated - Jason being asked for his views nearly every bloomin time.

Rated - Donal isnt he just cute!
slated - overall standard I think is way poorer than previous years.

Rated - Matt
slated - the costumes this year, like the skating standards have most certainly dropped!!

[quote=
Slated - Jason being asked for his views nearly every bloomin time.[/QUOTE]

Did they even ask Robin for his opinion last night or did he have to speak out of turn before Holly even noticed him?

I know Jason is portrayed as the bad guy but some of us want to hear what the other judges think too!

Rated - Coleen's routine - much improved now she's relaxed and enjoying it.

Slated - Pip's constant shouting. He doesn't do it on This Morning. I wonder if it's because he can't hear over the baying audience?

Rated - Kyran, Suzanne and Steves reactions to the performances when they were in the audience.
Slated - Gemmas reaction when she was in the auidence...

Great idea Saz

Rated Saz for bringing the idea over here

Rated: Todd Carty for making me howl with laughter last night

Slated: Ruth Henshall for moaning about over marking, then promptly doing exactly that.

Rated - Gemma being voted off last week
Slated - Not being able to see the show last night

Cheers Jude.

Rated: The new dance step they bring in every week
Rated: Todd's inane grin whilst nearly falling a over t

Slated: The constant ad breaks
Slated: Philip 'annoying 'Schofield

Great thread Sazzle!

Rated - egotistical Jeremy being sent home

Slated - Ruthie. Why is she there???

Rated: Todd's rictus grin.

Slated: Ad breaks

Rated - sequins - lots of them

Slated - Day Glo - fashion police alert alert

Rated: Running into Sid <smooch>

Rated: Colleen losing her fear

Rated: Zoes wobble right in front of the judges - well it made me laugh

Slated: I really need to get a life and stop posting!

Rated : Heyjude, we elevate posting to a level whereby it should be classified as work and therefore technically we all have a life

Rated : finding some familiar names and faces !!

Slated : people who can't differentiate between debate and debacle...

Slated - Todd Carty,


Slated - Todd Carty,


Slated - did I mention Todd Carty?

Rated: Todd for making me laugh so much I cried

Slated: Todd for making my family think I've now lost it

Coooey Jude <smooch>


Bonjour Miss M! <smooch>

It's nice to see so many of the SCD posters again. I think I might get into this series of DOI after all

OK back to the thread...

Rated - Colleen's hubby. I have developed a crush on him. Don't ask.

Slated - The rowdy audience.

Milagrosa - Yay, Am recognising more and more of you.

Have to say DOI doesn't do it for me in the way SCD did but hey better than nothing!

Rated: Former SCD Poster Redcurrant is now a newbie father.

Rated: The series is coming along nicely.

Slated: Too much Philip Schofield

Hi Sofa, I didn't realise that I was so big you couldn't see all of me at the same time

Rated: Chris and Jayne

Slated: Flourescent green costumes, I spent 10 minutes adjusting my TV

That's good to hear. A great poster, knows how to debate and deal with those who can't.

Rated - Redcurrant and his "friend" Rueful Rabbit
Slated - (In case anyone is going to say it I will) "annoying isn't when other posters turn a thread into an personal chat", sorry folks, please don't slate me, but the news about Redcurrant made me smile.

back to DoI

Rated - Robin Cousins chairing a panel better than grumpy Len
Slated - Jason not doing nasty as cleverly as Craig

Hi lightonmyfeet. I don't mind a bit of personal chat on here. The Beeb Rated thread was like that in the end! But we must endeavour to mention DOI cos the mods here have already moved 'Is it REALLY me' off the SCD pages and onto chatter - where it has died a death - because there wasn't enough SCD chat.

Great news about daddy Redcurrant. Good to recognise some of the names on here too.

Rated - Karen Barber's new hairstyle.
Rated - Jason has ditched the 'I must have a look' for each series idea. Remember the polo neck jumpers???

Slated - Some of Holly's maternity frock horrors. I can't decide who is dressed worse - her or Tess!

Rated: A lovely sense of deja vu
Slated: Not being sure whether it is deja vu or senility

Well hello Kaereste you wee minx!

Rated: Jason being most handsome judge

Slated: Jason being pompous a**e