Hoping to get a poll for this but in the meantime please comment. Who is your favourite judge and why? who is the most fair or most consistent?

I think Robin is the most consistent / fairest but i really like Karen and Nicky too.

Please vote for the most fair and then give your opinions on the others.

I think Karen is the most fair out of them all. I like Nicky and Robin.

Ruthie is coming across as hideously biased, especially towards Zoe.

I'd say Robin is the fairest of them.

Robin is kind of the head judge is he? just got that impression last week (tho its possible that this was said before )

Robin is the best for me. He's always polite and to the point.

Got to be Robin- always gets the marking right- and he has forgotten more about figure skating than Jason and Ruthie will ever learn

got to be Robin for me

Robin is the fairest.

Ruthie has her favourites and overmarks them.

Jason makes odd statements sometimes but overall I think he is quite fair too.

I think Karen, Nicky and Robin are the best judges. Ruthie has a go at Nicky for overmarking but she gives Jessica the same as Coleen and Melinda. I like the two of them but technically they certainly aren't better.

Robin Karen and Nicky i think are all good. Mind you they actually went out there and did it unlike the other two nonentities.

Robin. Although I like the nice guys, Nicky and Karen! Ruthie is the most inconsistent, at least Jason is hard on everybody.

Robin and Karen are fair and always try to give postive coments....Ruthie has her favourites and marks them high even when they don't deserve it. Nicky is out of step with everyone else and Jason, well he is.....I can't say or I might get banned!

Robin - fairest

Nicky & Karen - overmark (and are too nicey nicey)

Ruthie - utterly inconsistent

Jason - hard but consistent (and I enjoy his critiques!)

Robin, without a doubt.

yeah i think ruthie would be the least fair for me

Robin is the best judge by a long shot but I do like Karen also, she`s very encouraging and kind to the celebs.

Nicky is kind but his marking is erratic to say the least.

But she isn't supposed to be marking them technically. She's marking the overall artistic bit, that's why she's there, she knows diddly squat about ice skating technicalities.

She`s quite obvious with it too

Robin is the fairest and most consistant judge.

Nicky and Ruthie are to inconsistant
Karen is too close to the celebs to mark them properly
Jason - I just can't stant him. Don't like his marking, I don't think he's constructive. Horrible.

Robin - to the point and can always back up his scores.

poll up and running

Tempted to say Nicky, but he can be so erratic at times... so Robin got my vote - as along with being fair he's very consistent with it too.

Ruthie getting some votes

Nicky is the only judge who marked correctly tonight imo

Like basically everyone else, I agree with Robin.

Ruthie and Jason are guilty of judging too harshly and Nicky and Karen too nicely.