How would you have scored the couples’ performances from the latest show?

Melinda & Fred
Ray & Maria
Zoe & Matt
Ellery & Frankie
Coleen & Stuart
Donal & Florentine
Michael & Melanie
Roxanne & Daniel
Todd & Susie
Jessica & Pavel

Melinda & Fred: 3.0
Ray & Maria: 4.5
Zoe & Matt: 4.0
Ellery & Frankie: 3.0
Coleen & Stuart: 2.5
Donal & Florentine: 3.0
Michael & Melanie: 3.5
Roxanne & Daniel: 4.0
Todd & Susie: 1.5
Jessica & Pavel: 5.0

Melinda & Fred: 3.5 - hated the outfit, she didn't skate on her own and a stumble here and there (no worse than Zoe on the night)
Ray & Maria: 4.5 - little stumble and it was still streets ahead of any other male skater.
Zoe & Matt: 3.5 - annoyed that she scored so highly as she did no solo skating at all and still looked shaky
Ellery & Frankie: 3.0 - looks uncomfortable on the ice sometimes but a very good lift
Coleen & Stuart: 2.5 - relies on Stuart too much and not particularly stable on the ice. (Bottom 2 really)
Donal & Florentine: 3.5 - content was worth this alone even with a fall - also progression
Michael & Melanie: 3.5 - better this week, nice skate and certainly didn't deserve to be eliminated.
Roxanne & Daniel: 4.0 - solo skating was attempted and she's right at least she's trying.
Todd & Susie: 1 - awful programme and terrible skating to boot.
Jessica & Pavel: 5.0 - my fave of the night and undermarked from Ruthie

I thought the judges got a few of the scores badly wrong.
Last edited by Eviesmum : 03-02-2009 at 18:54

Melinda & Fred: 2.5
Ray & Maria: 4.5
Zoe & Matt: 4.0
Ellery & Frankie: 3.0
Coleen & Stuart: 2.0
Donal & Florentine: 3.5
Michael & Melanie: 3.0
Roxanne & Daniel: 3.5
Todd & Susie: 1.0
Jessica & Pavel: 4.5

Melinda & Fred: 3.0 - She's my favourite female but the song choice and choreography were poor.

Ray & Maria: 5.0 - Even though he annoys the hell out of me, I can't dent the boy can skate.

Zoe & Matt: 3.5 - I'm failing to understand the hype surrounding Zoe.

Ellery & Frankie: 3.0 - He hasn't built on the potential demonstrated on week 1.

Colleen & Stuart: 2.5 - Lovely lady and I admire her attitude but this performance left me underwhelmed.

Donal & Florentine: 4.5 - Loved it!

Michael & Melanie: 3.5 - Not bad but not brilliant either.

Roxanne & Daniel: 3.5 - This couple don't suit each other, but it was a competent enough display.

Todd & Susie: 1.0 - Desperate.

Jessica & Pavel: 4.0 - Can't connect yet with Jess even though she's clearly very good.

I agree with the majority of your scores

Melinda & Fred: 3.0
Ray & Maria: 5.0
Zoe & Matt: 4.0
Ellery & Frankie: 2.5
Colleen & Stuart: 2.5
Donal & Florentine: 4.0
Michael & Melanie: 3.5
Roxanne & Daniel: 3.0
Todd & Susie: 1.0
Jessica & Pavel: 4.0

Hopefully, the next 'your scores' thread will be a bit more successful.

My prediction of how i would score is, without seeing how they perform.

Melinda & Fred 4
Ray & Maria 5.5
Zoe & Matt 4
Ellery & Frankie 3.5
Coleen & Stuart 3.5
Donal & Florentine 4
Michael & Melanie N/A
Roxanne & Daniel 4.5
Todd & Susie 3
Jessica & Pavel 5

How can you score without seeing them perform, particularly giving Todd a 3.

I don't understand either.

I've obviously misread this thread. i thought we are giving them scores for this coming sunday. Not last Sunday ooops!!!

Oh, I see.

Don't worry, on_tender_hooks.