I don't think that'll go down well with the majority, even if it was said to Jason!

Why?

I liked it.

I think she'd have been better saying nothing or thank you but I don't think shes done much harm to her status though.

IMO its not what she said but the way she said it. She came across as very arrogant and as though he knows nothing in comparison to her, and that she knows her routine was the best ever etc.

If it was said in a more lighthearted way, maybe coming across as more in jest then I don't think there would be a problem.

But I think she'll be in the bottom 2 tonight whether or not she said it.

Can you blame her? I think the public will be on her side, shes' put up with it for weeks, and its not even constructive anymore, just plain nastiness.

How is she supposed to feel when he basically says that he doesnt want to watch her perform?

If it was said by say, Ruthie to Nicky Slater there would be outrage.
The sheep like booing over Jason's comments last week and this week is quite frankly disgusting whatever you think of him. Booing because he's just suggested dance classes - well, I think its a good idea and Donal did better by them.
Philip Schofield is constantly goading the audience. Well I suppose Jason doesnt care as he gets well paid, al the same its unprofessional and I cringe when he's asked for comments. Cant they ask another judge for the views for a change?

That's because Nicky and Ruthie wouldnt dare say what Jason did! They have some respect.

Every week Jason gets to comment on Roxanne which is wrong and every week he gives her insulting comments. I would have said worse he just dislikes her and is not even subtle about it.

She was calmer than I would've been!
She tries so hard every week and for Jason to say that it's like going to the Dentist, you don't look forward to it, is BOUND to tick her off.

He wasn't remotely nasty. Every word of it was sweetly coated constructive criticism. She's a brat for responding the way she does.

"I never look forward to seeing you perform"
"Like a sack of potatoes"

Erm, sounds nasty to me?

He meant the way she was picked up and swung around was like a sack of potatoes and it was.
And he said her leg lines were bad and they were. He also said he wanted her to improve but at the time the chavvy audience were booing so it probably couldnt be heard.
But I suppose the celebs are goaded into saying something rude back and show no respect at all to judges who know their trade.

It wasn't nasty, it was truthful. Did you see that last lift? They knew they did it wrong and it was extremely laboured. He gave her tips and she just whined and got aggressive back at him. Every other contestant is capable of taking criticism with a smile. Roxanne needs to grow up and start doing the same - maybe her skating would be better then.

I agree. However, I am slowly starting to warm to Roxanne.

lmao if you say so.

IMO Roxanne has had nothing but nastiness from Jason, and it all seems very unwarranted.

Jason gives Melinda, Ellery even Todd constructive criticism, but when it comes to Roxanne he loses all manners which is unfair, and the way she snapped at him tonight shows that shes came to a breaking point.

She's been pleasant to him every week until this week, (Or last week though her comment was IMO tongue in cheek) and I dont understand how you can say she needs to grow up? She's only human and can take so much.

Exactly he just likes the sound of his own voice.

I thought it was pretty funny myself, Jason seems to have been nothing but nasty to her and if i'm honest he deserved it.

Jason's opinion of Roxanne reminds of Samantha Mumba. He clearly didn't like her, and it showed. The same thing seems to be happening with Roxanne.

Personally I think it would have been better if she had kept quiet. He wasn' the only one who gave her a 3, he was giving her constructive criticism. I like Roxy but I always feel uneasy when she skates, she doesn't seem to flow on the ice.

I completely agree and I don't think Roxy was being a brat or that she snapped. She was asked to make a comment by Phillip and she made a light-hearted jokey comment that even Jason, who clearly doesn't like her, smiled at.

Unfortunately, she is a none too bright chav - it was a cr@ppy comeback.

LMAO.
A chav for doing what? Defending herself? Sorry but your comment's ridiculous.

Personally I though Jason was being pretty restrained. He gave her some very constructive advice on how to improve but Roxy doesn't want to hear it unless he's going to sing her praises. The audiences behaviour is disgusting and should not be encouraged. Maybe she feels she is being singled out but to respond that way is distasteful. Urgh I hope the little madam gets the boot. She's not that good. Shame Dan got partnered with her as I'm a big fan of his.

Erm, no, she is a chav.......because, she is a chav........her comeback was not very clever and frankly rather rubbish, a bit like your understanding of my previous post.

My dad laughed his head off when she said that - he's easily amused!