I could come up with a witty response but the fact you were emasculated by post number one to try to demean somebody with an pseudo-academic response I will say...
My gracious child; The record industry and all industries in the known capitalist and free market communist universes all "MANUFACTURE" in order to appeal to a "MARKET".
Plenty of bands make it based on their own unique sound an songs. In fact most groups with lasting appeal. Coldplay, Muse etc. Their output at least CAN reflect who they are, CAN be indicative of them.In no sense does Joes output reflect him, nor is it actually from him. He sings a song written by somebody else, backed by musicians (since he has no musical talent beyond singing).
I'm not questioning whether a product is sold. I'm questioning the value of the product. As did others.
Plenty of bands make it based on their own unique sound an songs. In fact most groups with lasting appeal. Coldplay, Muse etc. Their output reflects who they are, is indicative of them.In no sense does Joes output reflect him, nor is it actually from him. He sings a song written by somebody else, backed by musicians (since he has no musical talent beyond singing).
I think you your view of musical talent is driven by a manufactured world.
Socialist Smelly Protesters who like RATM for a couple of weeks deluding themselves they are not manufactured
VS
The MIGHTY Kablamo
I don't think they are Socialist Smelly Protesters, I think they are all terribly well brought up young people being a bit anarchic because someone told them to. I'm sure you are mighty though!
I could come up with a witty response but the fact you were emasculated by post number one to try to demean somebody with an pseudo-academic response I will say...
I just take great pride in breaking dreams and then seeing posters try in vain to emasculate other posters because their fantasy driven identity on a forum has been destroyed to the point all they are left with are simple insults because they will be destroyed at the flick of a wrist if they even attempted to debate the matter.
Ya get me?
I doubt it but continue with attempting to emasculate matters Monsieur Billy " manufactured bleach blonde hair " Idol.
I think you your view of musical talent is driven by a manufactured world.
Your definition of manufactured is obviously so wide, that because you deem this a "manufactured world" everything is "manufactured" by default anyway. You appear to think that if an artist doesn't change, its because they are scared of alientated their fanbase and damaging their product. You leave ZERO room for the fact that people are creatures of habit. For instance someone like John Denver released country music because of his interests, outlook and upbringing. He would've hardly been comfortable bringing out a drum and bass, or dance album. Sometimes what people present you with and its familiarity is because they are creatures of habit, rather than a decision in a boardroom. I'm not saying that that doesn't occur, because it obviously does, but your extreme viewpoint, is no more logical than the view you attack.
I just take great pride in breaking dreams and then seeing posters try in vain to emasculate other posters because their fantasy driven identity on a forum has been destroyed to the point all they are left with are simple insults because they will be destroyed at the flick of a wrist if they even attempted to debate the matter.
Ya get me?
I doubt it but continue with attempting to emasculate matters Monsieur Billy " manufactured bleach blonde hair " Idol.
I bow to your Internet superiority, thy master. But i welcome you to destroy me. As i do not care anymore.
This is all abit cryptic. 'one' must know they need to take a break from the internet when they are conversing with a faceless username in coded messages on a forum. Y et still fully indulging themselves in it. I digress. Wouldnt you say so Beer?
The poster likes to use the word emasculated. Do you think he has been?
Of course not.
How can I be emasculated when I don't need pseudo-tools of masculinity like joining a left wing group or joining a face book group to say "Woo - look at me! We stand up for some group because the media told us too".
The world is emasculated. The MIGHTY Kablamo is all Man!
I bow to your Internet superiority, thy master (Ed: What?). But i welcome you to destroy me. As i do not care anymore.
This is all abit cryptic. 'one' must know they need to take a break from the internet when they are conversing with a faceless username in coded messages on a forum. Y et still fully indulging themselves in it. I digress. Wouldnt you say so Beer?
What in the hell are you talking about!?
I feel that the original post has not only emasculated you but given you some bizarre delusion of grandeur from the safety of a one man island.
Seriously now; this is just a forum. I think you need to take a piece of your medicine and take a break from the internet if you seriously take it so seriously.
How can I be emasculated when I don't need pseudo-tools of masculinity like joining a left wing group or joining a face book group to say "Woo - look at me! We stand up for some group because the media told us too".
The world is emasculated. The MIGHTY Kablamo is all Man!
Comments
Yawn City, Idaho.
Do you often refer to yourself in the 3rd person? Are you Katie Price?
No. It is:
Joe McElderry Fans
VS
Socialist Smelly Protesters who like RATM for a couple of weeks deluding themselves they are not manufactured
VS
The MIGHTY Kablamo
^^^^^^
True.
Plenty of bands make it based on their own unique sound an songs. In fact most groups with lasting appeal. Coldplay, Muse etc. Their output at least CAN reflect who they are, CAN be indicative of them.In no sense does Joes output reflect him, nor is it actually from him. He sings a song written by somebody else, backed by musicians (since he has no musical talent beyond singing).
I'm not questioning whether a product is sold. I'm questioning the value of the product. As did others.
Oh go and dream about the next left wing protest where you can massage your ego by shouting.
I am about to drink a whole load of beer. I'll pop back later if I can find something ironically funny to say
I think you your view of musical talent is driven by a manufactured world.
I don't think they are Socialist Smelly Protesters, I think they are all terribly well brought up young people being a bit anarchic because someone told them to. I'm sure you are mighty though!
EH? Im with stupid:D
I just take great pride in breaking dreams and then seeing posters try in vain to emasculate other posters because their fantasy driven identity on a forum has been destroyed to the point all they are left with are simple insults because they will be destroyed at the flick of a wrist if they even attempted to debate the matter.
Ya get me?
I doubt it but continue with attempting to emasculate matters Monsieur Billy " manufactured bleach blonde hair " Idol.
...of smelly left wing socialist protesters.
Absolutely.
It appears the level of education ends in the humanities department and the smokers corner with their indie bands for some.
Your definition of manufactured is obviously so wide, that because you deem this a "manufactured world" everything is "manufactured" by default anyway. You appear to think that if an artist doesn't change, its because they are scared of alientated their fanbase and damaging their product. You leave ZERO room for the fact that people are creatures of habit. For instance someone like John Denver released country music because of his interests, outlook and upbringing. He would've hardly been comfortable bringing out a drum and bass, or dance album. Sometimes what people present you with and its familiarity is because they are creatures of habit, rather than a decision in a boardroom. I'm not saying that that doesn't occur, because it obviously does, but your extreme viewpoint, is no more logical than the view you attack.
I bow to your Internet superiority, thy master. But i welcome you to destroy me. As i do not care anymore.
This is all abit cryptic. 'one' must know they need to take a break from the internet when they are conversing with a faceless username in coded messages on a forum. Y et still fully indulging themselves in it. I digress. Wouldnt you say so Beer?
Why does that automatically make one better than the other? Plenty of musicians write their own music but it's not all good material.
Of course not.
How can I be emasculated when I don't need pseudo-tools of masculinity like joining a left wing group or joining a face book group to say "Woo - look at me! We stand up for some group because the media told us too".
The world is emasculated. The MIGHTY Kablamo is all Man!
What in the hell are you talking about!?
I feel that the original post has not only emasculated you but given you some bizarre delusion of grandeur from the safety of a one man island.
Seriously now; this is just a forum. I think you need to take a piece of your medicine and take a break from the internet if you seriously take it so seriously.
You are certainly all something.