Have to admit that for the first time hearing her 'real' voice was a surprise. But it was just okay, not great by any means. More importantly it showed clearly that she was not comfortable with the genre.
agree i dont like her at all , but she was better tonight so i give credit where it is due, but when Cowell said the best of the "season":D:D i know it is a "stop hating CHER" pr but dont take us for idiots you manipulating d**k.
Compared with Rebecca and TreyC she was far from it - shaky and warbly snd unable to get to the high votes. And as much as I dislike Matt, his vocals were far superior.
I think people dislike her as a person more then what talent she has, I know I do, she was good tonight, but how can you really praise someone for "singing" in a singing competition.
agree i dont like her at all , but she was better tonight so i give credit where it is due, but when Cowell said the best of the "season":D:D i know it is a "stop hating CHER" pr but dont take us for idiots you manipulating d**k.
There was no way in a million years was she better than Rebecca. Plus I didn't see any tears for gods sake lol!
its was good but its wasnt as amazing as the judges said seriously she was off key at least twice i thought at least ONE judge would have picked that up.
I'll admit - not normally a fan of hers but thought she was one of the better ones tonight, I agree I found her voice a bit weak but I liked her performance overall
There was very heavy production on most performances this evening. Some of the backing was much louder than the actual contestant.
Cher, however, was stripped back and we heard every note. It was rather beautiful.
I still think that she shouldn't have felt forced to do it. She should be what she wants to be, as should the others. Then, win or lose, they have remained true to themselves.
Comments
She was okay dude... Nothing to write about though.. Performance of the series my arse.
Me too.:eek:
I did think that.
agree i dont like her at all , but she was better tonight so i give credit where it is due, but when Cowell said the best of the "season":D:D i know it is a "stop hating CHER" pr but dont take us for idiots you manipulating d**k.
NO REBECCA, PAIGE AND TREY C WERE OUTSTANDING
She certainly won me over because I thought she was an Ali G wannbe who couldn't sing.
She performed extremely well for someone who can't sing.
There is something in that
There was no way in a million years was she better than Rebecca. Plus I didn't see any tears for gods sake lol!
They will look for something to hate. I'm not a fan, but it's a bit stupid with some of the comments sometimes.
She was brilliant tonight.
Matt on the other hand was embarassing.
none the less it was the performance of the night as the show was the car crash i expected, utterly dreadful all round.
Hm some people have too much pride to drastically change their opinions *shakes head*
I agree, I was disappointed with matt tonight
Cher, however, was stripped back and we heard every note. It was rather beautiful.
I still think that she shouldn't have felt forced to do it. She should be what she wants to be, as should the others. Then, win or lose, they have remained true to themselves.
She was still bloody good though!!!!!
After watching her performance again, I 100% take this back
Thread closed.