Options
Shocking - The Truth About The Audition Process!
![[Deleted User]](https://w5.vanillicon.com/v2/558a6b2b52fad17a1ec84bfc1252c027.svg)
[Deleted User]
Posts: 477 Forum Member
✭
Very interesting article about what goes on behind the scenes of the auditions before acts ever get to perform to the judges. Looks like contestants get treated like dirt until they get to the judges.
Queuing for 11 hours to sing two lines of a song and a producer tells you NO. You ask "Why?" knowing you can hold a tune and he replies, "We don't give feedback, go on home".
The team tell the crowd to scream and wave, the crowd thinking it's to warm them up. Not true, the editors later edit in videos of the judges arriving to crowds of thousands of people so it looks like they stay there all day judging people.
The team also hand out signs to the crowd with "I Love Simon, Cheryl, Danni etc.".
Sounds horrible and the television show is so misleading. I knew there was a few auditions before the Judges audition but this is unbelievable.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/entertainment/8209429.stm
Queuing for 11 hours to sing two lines of a song and a producer tells you NO. You ask "Why?" knowing you can hold a tune and he replies, "We don't give feedback, go on home".
The team tell the crowd to scream and wave, the crowd thinking it's to warm them up. Not true, the editors later edit in videos of the judges arriving to crowds of thousands of people so it looks like they stay there all day judging people.
The team also hand out signs to the crowd with "I Love Simon, Cheryl, Danni etc.".
Sounds horrible and the television show is so misleading. I knew there was a few auditions before the Judges audition but this is unbelievable.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/entertainment/8209429.stm
0
Comments
It is an entertainment show... just!
Did you think it was a talent show?
Oh, and um... 2009?
Several people I know didnt even make it in front of the judges, just being told your not what were looking for (and they have been on the semi-pro circuit singing in propper bands - you know with instruments and stuff - for years).
The ones that get in front of the Judges are either:
1. Freeks/Jokes
2. Have an attitude proble/think there gods gift
3. Have a decent enough voice BUT also a sob story/dont fit the pop star look
4. Have good looks and a voice to go with it.
You can be a world class singer - but if your just ordinary/average looking you wont even get to the judges.
Sorry to burst any bubbles - but thats how its always been. It is NOT (as its billed) taking average Joe off the streets and giving them a chance.
But yes, we knew it was a contrived process. It's just an entertainment show. And all 'talent' shows have been the same since the beginning. Opportunity Knocks, Stars In Their Eyes, Fame Academy, etc. The Voice will be the same.
Lots of shows give out signs or offer the tools to make them on the day.
Where have you been OP?
I think it's a bit unfair that the production staff in the first round don't give any feedback though!
Once inside again there was more waiting but you know that and from what my friend who went up to audition said, he sang more than 2 lines and although he got a no was treated perfectly fine by the producer.
Chart Throb by Ben Elton gives a good insight into the process. I believe he said at the time his info came from people in the industry.
I went with my cousin and if you are a fan of the show and how tv works, then I would highly recommend it. It is a very long day and the filming can get tedious but if you approach it as a fun day out, then it will be a fun day out. When I was at filming at the O2, they told us that we had to do crowd shots of us cheering and then we had to do shots of silent cheering, so they could have Dermot walking through the crowd and still be able to hear him. Every step of the process was explained.
There was one guy in a section who wouldn't stand up and cheer. He through a hissy fit and said that he was there to audition and didn't want to be part of any manipulation :rolleyes: The producer told him to either stand up and take part, or leave. He left. The producer then told the 20,000 people in the O2 that anyone who didn't want to take part in filming was free to leave. He made it clear that as you progressed through rounds, there would be more and more expected of you and anyone who couldn't handle that was best off going home.
It sounds harsh but I can't blame them. They are there to make a tv show and if everyone refused to take part in the basic things, then the show would be shite to watch. The manipulation which drives me mad is when they introduce a sing off in the semi-finals, after saying that it would be a public vote. That is seriously bad form. Expecting auditionees to put in a bit of effort and do some crowd cheering when they have been told even before arriving that that's what they should expect, isn't.
Auditions are a long way off but to anyone who does go, I would advise bringing lots of food and drink, don't expect to get through and just enjoy the day
To those who complain, look at it this way. We all see ads on the telly by the National Lottery, showing how all your dreams can come through if you simply buy a ticket and win. Does anyone act all outraged when they, shock, horror, don't win and become an instant millionaire? Of course not!
Just out of interest Mary, did anyone from your audition make it even as far as the televised audition.....did you recognise anyone?
The chances of getting to the judges, nevermind being televised are incredibly slim. The O2 can hold about 20,000 people. Roughly 12,000 of those are familiy members who have come for support and out of the 8,000 who actually audition, only 40 will get as far as the judges. From those 40, maybe 2 or 3 will get shown on tv. The chances of getting through are very slim and it's not enough to have a good voice, you have to make good tv.
Edit: I remember seeing a guy dressed in yellow bright clothes who got as far as the judges but got a no. He was obviously a novelty act. I'll try and find his audition. He was a nice guy and chatted to everyone
The reason I ask is that I suspect that the vast majority who attend the public audition don't get as far the judges, apart the ones who eventually get four 'no's.
Which means I'm suggesting that most of those who end up at bootcamp never actually tried out for the show at this initial audition at all. There are occasional exceptions of course : apparently Mary Byrne attended the initial public audition.
When I was going up to Dublin to see the audition show, I met someone on the bus who was auditioning. He had gone through all the auditions (he didn't get past the judges) and the main thing he said was that the producers went through his life looking for things to tell the media. He had a very middle class life and there was no scandal/backstory. He had a decent enough voice and I wonder was it the lack of media fodder that went against him?
I think the people who allegedly (:p) get the free pass are the exceptions, rather than the rule and the vast majority of people we see have gone through the whole process but the ones who get through are the ones not only with good/bad voices but also the ones who will generate the most media interest and are the most comfortable on camera. There is no point putting someone through who can sing but clams up as soon as a camera is put in their face. The contestants are interviewed constantly (and is why so many of them lose their voices) and it's ok to have a shy personality but if you cannot handle the camera's, then they won't put you through.
We'll have to agree to disagree Mary
:eek:
LOL, thanks for this, didnt know thats how it goes down.
Yeah;)