Options
Don't get the love for Melanie
Ronell_Davis
Posts: 4,415
Forum Member
✭✭✭
Before anyone attacks me it's just my opnion she can sing but I really don't think she is that special she just dosen't wow me and tonight just emphasised my reason for thinking this I can kind of see why she has never made the live shows .
0
Comments
Makes life interesting doesn't it?
Oh yeah she has a good voice too
There's nothing going on behind it, nothing interesting, nothing to grab you...
Agreed on this but she might show something different if she gets through to the live shows - she may prove some doubters like myself wrong
The One That Got Away though was truly the worst of her performances so far though - compared to both the audition ones which were very nice. She was flat straight off from the start and it just shouldn't have been that song she should be singing.
Tamera is the only one in those top six girls who has any genuine star quality. The others all range from good to really good, but that's not enough.
I really don't agree with that tbh
she probably knows this is her last chance , she had had to sit and watch every other act perform knowing she was the last act, and the pressure must have been immense, altho this is her 4th attempt she is still quite young and it is asking a lot of people to handle that type of situation
she strikes me as someone who tries to bottle up her emotions and wants to be seen as being in control all the time but tonight it all just got a bit too much for her and what you saw as an "act" I saw as someone being embarrassed about showing her emotions
I could imagine her on an Andrew Lloyd Webber show on the BBC - she just doesn't have The X Factor for me.
Tamera or Hannah would be a "shock" elimination. Melanie or Jade wouldn't.