Options
Is Hannah a one trick pony?
Jessica_Hamby
Posts: 1,622
Forum Member
✭✭✭
I don't like the Skyfall song anyway. I think it's very one dimensional and I didn't understand all the fuss that was made about it at the time, but I'm beginning ot think that Hannah is a bit of a one dimensional singer too. Maybe in a few years she can offer more variation but right now she seems to have only one timbre, one volume, one style, one level of emotional intensity.
Your thoughts?
Your thoughts?
Is Hannah a bit boring? 137 votes
Yes she is.
59%
81 votes
No she's not.
40%
56 votes
0
Comments
Anything different is weirdly seem as "limited," because that person can't belt out a song..
I think Hannah has a great range and is capable of tackling different types of song..
I do like Skyfall, but thought, if she were to go for a "Bond," songs then there would've been better options.
As it was, I thought it was an uneasy performance and weak in places..
Comments about her being the only person capable of tackling an "Adele," song were, wide of the mark.
I think the problem for Hannah will be trying to convince them that she could try something different..
Like with Sam Bailey, she seems to be on the ballad train and there's no getting off.
Rich.
x
Hannah only seems to be able to turn it up to 11, which she can do quite well, but she needs to be able to do more imo.
I thought the Skyfall performance was good, but she held back at the end. Maybe her voice is suffering and why she looked a bit miserable at the end. She knew she could do it better.
And i would never call her a one trick pony.
On another note, she needs to be more expressive with her eyes because the combination of the fire and her dead eyes this week made her look like a cold-blooded murderer instead of a 17-year old girl living her dream on a TV show.
Give her 5 years and the right instincts and she could become really good but right now..... I'm not so sure.
I reckon Hannah could sing Chaka Khan - I'm every woman for disco week this week a perfect song for her.
Excellent choice! It's empowering and upbeat.
It's interesting because there have been many allegations made against Tamera yet she seems to be doing well picking up votes. It just shows that people are really basing it on performance and not character.
Stupid poll to try to rile up the Hannah fans, but I answered it anyway!!
She has done uptempo...would like to see more soul and rap ala Misha stylee!!! :D
I thought Sky Fall failed because it was too copycat. It sounded like exactly the same arrangement as the Adele version but wasn't as good as the Adele version (not that I'm a huge fan of the song anyway).
Mind you, Sam Bailey's stuff is often very like the original but it is so good you just don't mind for some reason
Edit: I didn't vote as I wanted a "Don't Know" option
Did James Brown do ballads?
Did Morrissey do thrash metal?
Did Kurt Cobain do hip hop?
Did Shane MacGowan do disco?
No........and thank goodness.
Do you have to be so rude for no reason what so ever?
Wlell you must have been watching a different singer to me then if you think that.
So very true.