My suspect panel

DrPepper · 28/05/15 - 15:23

With all the speculation I thought I'd chip in..

From left to right:

Gary Barlow...Tulisa...Cheryl...Simon

pjh8 · 28/05/15 - 15:45

I'm thinking
Nick Grimshaw,Tinie Tempah/Demi/Tulisa, Cheryl & Simon

amanda daisy · 28/05/15 - 18:14

As much as I'd love seeing Gary again weekly, he won't return to XF. He's busy touring till October/November and he's already working on a new album with TT.

The panel will probably be Simon, Demi, Cheryl and Nick.

BRITLAND · 28/05/15 - 18:19

I think it's looking like:
Simon
Cheryl (sadly)
Female Boss (maybe Demi but Female Boss more likely sadly)
Nick (sadly)

If we're getting rid of Louis then it appears we must someone just as annoying to replace him, or in the eye of Simon anyway.

casa_nova · 28/05/15 - 20:55

Maybe Olly should of been a judge with Ellie Golding. Caroline Flack presenting on her own.

Simon Cheryl Olly Murs Ellie Golding would of been a good line up.

casa_nova · 28/05/15 - 20:56

Or Enrique Ingelsias replacing Louis.

DrPepper · 28/05/15 - 21:21

amanda daisy wrote: »

As much as I'd love seeing Gary again weekly, he won't return to XF. He's busy touring till October/November and he's already working on a new album with TT.

The panel will probably be Simon, Demi, Cheryl and Nick.

It's just been suspiciously quiet about Gary on the rumours....and pitching him and X against Simon and Cheryl would clearly divide the panel - so it'd be different.

If he's not available then he's not (I didn't check tour dates), but if he is the promo for TT wouldn't hurt either.

Anyway, it probably won't happen....but it would be the most interesting mix of all I think.

Dalekbuster523 · 28/05/15 - 22:31

Unfortunately, it looks to be:

Simon, Cheryl, Demi, Nick

Dalekbuster523 · 28/05/15 - 22:34

DrPepper wrote: »

It's just been suspiciously quiet about Gary on the rumours....and pitching him and X against Simon and Cheryl would clearly divide the panel - so it'd be different.

If he's not available then he's not (I didn't check tour dates), but if he is the promo for TT wouldn't hurt either.

Anyway, it probably won't happen....but it would be the most interesting mix of all I think.

Can't see them having two Mr Nasty personas on the same series. Although it would be interesting to see a crossover between two different X Factor panels (something truly unique which has never been done with a talent show contest before).

Wong_Billabong · 28/05/15 - 23:31

No more old judges please!!!

BRITLAND · 29/05/15 - 11:15

casa_nova wrote: »

Or Enrique Ingelsias replacing Louis.

Forgot about him, and I don't think Little Mix ruled him out either, with the rumour of Cheryl as the only female judge, we might see:
Simon
Cheryl
Nick
Enrique

Interesting eh?

[Deleted User] · 29/05/15 - 15:53

Louis Tomlinson, Sara Cox, Cheryl Cole, Simon Cowell

Nick Grimshaw, Demi Lovato, Cheryl Cole, Simon Cowell.

THEXFACTORKING · 30/05/15 - 06:49

I think the entire chopping and changing of judges is what made the show a hjoke, and turned off some people.

Should have been kept as Dannii, Cheryl, Louis, and Simon until the show was axed.

DrPepper · 02/06/15 - 13:58

True but it is what it is now so it might as well be an entertaining part, hopefully with some credibility.

I'm gonna struggle with Grimmy who doesn't even select what to play on Radio 1, he just sticks to the playlist he's given and he has no more credibility than me to judge on performance....but we'll see.

I'd like someone like Gavin Bain (Sillibil and Brains) - vast industry experience but with an interesting and different enough backstory to stand out from 'normal' performers.

StrictlyEastend · 02/06/15 - 14:37

BRITLAND wrote: »

I think it's looking like:
Simon
Cheryl (sadly)
Female Boss (maybe Demi but Female Boss more likely sadly)
Nick (sadly)

If we're getting rid of Louis then it appears we must someone just as annoying to replace him, or in the eye of Simon anyway.

I hope it isn't that panel. What do you mean by female boss?

I would want

Simon
Nicole
Sharon
Louis. (As much as he annoys me, I always love to see what ridiculous act he puts through!)

StrictlyEastend · 02/06/15 - 14:38

THEXFACTORKING wrote: »

I think the entire chopping and changing of judges is what made the show a hjoke, and turned off some people.

Should have been kept as Dannii, Cheryl, Louis, and Simon until the show was axed.

I agree. I miss Dannii from the X factor.

BRITLAND · 02/06/15 - 14:57

StrictlyEastend wrote: »

I hope it isn't that panel. What do you mean by female boss?

I would want

Simon
Nicole
Sharon
Louis. (As much as he annoys me, I always love to see what ridiculous act he puts through!)

Tulisa, isn't that what she used to call herself, the female boss?

StrictlyEastend · 02/06/15 - 15:25

BRITLAND wrote: »

Tulisa, isn't that what she used to call herself, the female boss?

Oh, right, sorry, I didn't understand it but I do now.

[Deleted User] · 07/06/15 - 19:38

Probably Simon, Louie, Tulisa and Rita or Demi. This panel would not be that bad.

Wong_Billabong · 07/06/15 - 19:43

Kayleigh-M wrote: »

Probably Simon, Louie, Tulisa and Rita or Demi. This panel would not be that bad.

Forgetting Cheryl who's about as confirmed as simon :cool:

[Deleted User] · 07/06/15 - 19:51

Wong_Billabong wrote: »

Forgetting Cheryl who's about as confirmed as simon :cool:[/QUOT
OK, I will replace Simon, with Will.I.am.

[Deleted User] · 07/06/15 - 19:52

Wong_Billabong wrote: »

Forgetting Cheryl who's about as confirmed as simon :cool:[/QUOT
OK, I will replace Simon, with Will.I.am. (Just pretending Cheryl does not exist):)

Hey there!

Quick Links

My suspect panel

Comments