Options
Simon needs to take a break and Judges replaced...
evangeline007
Posts: 2,169 Forum Member
✭✭✭
Ok the nation loves variety, but this series needs mending. Simon looks miserable and should step back and let someone fresh and exciting take the helm. The Judges especially Amanda and the best friends act with Simon need to go. They seem to think they are super talented but really they are in a cosy rut. I assume no one can advise Simon in an objective way due to the fact he owns the format, you have to agree and keep in with him: e.g Amanda to stay and get public exposure I guess. I would get Louis Walsh, Sharon Osbourne, Ashlee Banjo and Rylan. People along these lines.It is a great show but the Judges are killing it.
0
Comments
I would like to see David and Amanda go, . I liked Alesha until her disgracful behaviour pressing Amanda and David's buzzers during a live show.
Maybe ten years is long enough for BGT.
Don't put that gimp Rylan anywhere near it
I couldn't agree more (well, except for the bit about Rylan
I also think they would benefit from doing the show every couple of years rather than annually, although they probably should have started doing that since it started.
Totally agree with above esp bit about the act needing to be on screen till they stop.
So if Amanda is seen smiling with pride, the viewers is being made to think the act is good.
If Simon is seen laughing, the viewers are supposed to find the act hilarious (which can fail, some "funny" acts leave me stone faced as I just don't find them that funny!!!)
Etc...it's all part of the editing even on a live show.
They have all been signed up for another year according to simon think it's a mistake.
would love Sharon to be on it and ashley banjo no chance till 2017.
The audience are obviously being hyped up to yell and scream on demand to the point where the acts themselves cannot be heard. When they watch other 'stars' not involved in the competition , they react in a normal way - simply watching and then applauding at the end as we saw in the final.
The 'judges' are the 'best act' on the show . They must spend hours in coaching to learn the surprised/amazed/disbelieving expressions they regularly adopt - not to mention all that leaping to their feet at the drop of a hat to demonstrate their appreciation of an act they are later perfectly happy to vote off.
The acts themselves ...more than in any previous years ... include 'turns' brought in from similar programmes in other countries - and as such are not in any way a representation of 'British Talent' .
So , despite all the hype , the show appears contrived, tired and 'rigged'.
Time for a break ? For sure !
Although Simon did grate on me with the stupid acts he supported this year. He can still stay though.
I would be quite happy to see Rylan there. I really like him actually. Anyone acting all aghast at the thought of Rylan, obviously hasn't seen him on tv properly for any length of time. He's funny and interesting to listen to, and does well at interviewing.
It would also be nice if the acts were genuine amateur acts too. Not scouted, stage school brats, and semi professionals.
For me, it would feel incredibly weird not seeing Amanda on the Britain's Got Talent panel. I think Alesha's okay. I can't be bothered with David, especially when he gives a 'yes' to a very average, and below average act.
Totally agree about Alesha's behaviour. She should be ashamed of herself.
How? Can't find it online.
Maybe just easier if you said what you mean
Agree SC is too old and too out of touch now, and far to scruffy, he needs to retire.
They're doing X Factor so can't see them doing BGT
They work so well together and are the most fun judging panel on British TV. Doesn't need changing at all.